Shah’s definition. - - >
Shahmaran wrote: dude its the intention, the reason, for the killings plus a substantial amount of successfull kills that makes it GENOCIDE!
And subsequent rumblings: --- >
wrote: Holocaust was genocide (first legally recognised one), TCs was genocide, Armenians was not genocide!!!!
Here Shah tells us there was intention (ho ho just because he claims so) to wipe off the ethnic group of TCs of 120,000 people plus a substantial amount of successful killings i.e 800 dead within 14 years during their own fights that also resulted to 400 GC dead that can term the death of those people as "genocide"
Following the same Shahi logic the 1.5 million wiped off Armenians was not genocide, because hey there was no intention, they just died by accident, it was war time, such things can happen, there was starvasion, many Turks died too, blah blah blah.
wrote: BECAUSE IT WAS NOT GENOCIDE AND ITS NOTHING TO DO WITH THE NUMBERS!!!!
And his above screaming says, hey since it is already established that there was no intent, then there was no Genocide, it just happened by accident, the numbers thus become totally irrelevant. It could have been 1 million, it could have been 2 million it could have been 2.5 million out of the 2.5 million Armenians.
Is this what you are trying to tell us all along Shahi boy? Lets have a straight answer and let us play your own game in your own filed. Waiting…..!!
NB. Here’s a nice link for your educational purposes. Do you see Turkey listed anywhere near Hitlers Germany? Ny idea why is Turkey listed?
http://www.hawaii.edu/powerkills/GENOCIDE.ENCY.HTM
Taking both social definitions into account, governments have murdered probably around 174 million people during the 20th Century. Most of this killing, perhaps around 110 million people, is due to communist governments, especially the USSR under Lenin and Stalin and their successors (62 million murdered), and China under Mao Tse-tung (35 million). Some other totalitarian or authoritarian governments are also largely responsible for this toll, particularly Hitler's Germany (21 million murdered) and Chiang Kai-chek's Nationalist government of China (about 10 million). Other governments that have murdered lesser millions include Khmer Rouge Cambodia, Japan, North Korea, Mexico, Pakistan, Poland, Russia, Turkey, Vietnam, and Tito's Yugoslavia