Alexandros Lordos wrote:Would you be content with a Senate Equality that is not permanent? Would other TCs also feel the same way?
If all you need is a temporary derogation, I am sure that is not too difficult to arrange ... and if you want something more secure, it can be a derogation that will be put to referendum of the TC community 15 years from now, and then every 15 years after that, until they freely decide to abolish it ...
Temporary deroagtions are not acceptable for me right now under my current mindset and distrust to GCs.
But again, remember. Thee reason that I am not insisting on permament derogations, is not that I would not prefer tham. But I just simply believe that they are not legal not only in EU but also in ECHR as well, so they simply are not feasible to be implemented.
I mean even if the permanent deriogation is accepted by EU courts they will be turned from ECHR courts, unless we specify the law the way I defined it, by giving dual citizenship.
Because it is against "human rights" giving a person full citizenship rights but later on restrict their involvement in political participation. The only way you can do that is by saying that this guy is already using its human rights in the other state because he has dual citizenship.
But having said that, I also believe that if we can live together for 30 years without an incident, then we may essentailly start trusting each other, and may be feel secure that we will not be dominted by the GCs against our consent, so that derogations can be lifted.
It is kind of 'catch 22'. If we can live together enough we can trust each other and don't need permamanet derogations, but we can not live together long enough without those derogations.
Anyway that is my take on things,