After the recent disruptive events, a return to normality can only be conditional:
I will agree to return to normality and assist in the quick recovery of the forum, subject to the following new rules layout...
First ask yourselves, why are we here?
I like to think we’re here because we are interested in current affairs and other topics up for debate/argument in the company of mature adults. If you’re here only to just “get” at someone you dislike, then you are here for the wrong reasons and don’t belong here. In other words, a vindictive obsession is the wrong reason to be on a forum so to separate the wheat from the chaff we urgently need to introduce Self Policing to the forum.
The introduction of Self Policing:
Self policing is the act of being familiar with some basic rules laid out and everyone being part of the Executive in carrying out or executing those rules (law). If everyone is part of the Executive then you’ll find that threads/debates run much more smoothly and civilized but one needs to actively participate for this to work so don’t get lazy. Self Policing means that EVERYONE is a forum moderator pursuing justice. Now let’s move onto some basic rules…
Rule 1: Posts must be relevant to the subject at hand:
Example: A “Ronald Reagan making jokes” video, in the middle of the Ukraine thread is NOT relevant to the topic at hand.
You are the Executive: This behavior should be condemned by ALL and sundry and failure to condemn it means you approve of this behavior and encourage chaos. You are expected to confront the offender with a…”Mate, this is NOT relevant to the topic at hand!” or something along those lines.
Rule 2: The art of countering and personal attacks:
When countering an argument one must quote and address the specific line or lines they are responding to, but NOT the person.
You’re meant to stick to the CONTENT posted when countering, not the person! A simple example…
Bad counter: “I think you’re stupid!” <-- this is a personal attack because there’s no argument.
Good counter: “I think you’re stupid because... blah…. blah… blah” <-- this is a spicy argument
You are the Executive: A personal attack with no argument should be condemned by ALL and sundry and failure to condemn it means you approve of this behavior that can lead to forum chaos.
Rule 3: Refraining from obsessions with other members:
If you happen to be obsessed with someone go see a therapist but don’t keep bringing up that person’s name in every other sentence and every other post, as we don’t care about your obsession and you should learn to recognize your obsession (the person lives in your head like 24/7) and withdraw from the forum until you are cured! Obsessions are CREEPY and horrible and need to be stopped immediately!
You are the Executive: An obvious obsession should be condemned by ALL and sundry and failure to condemn it means you approve of this behavior that can lead to forum chaos.
Rule 4: The dreaded incessant videos:
Videos, although good as supporting material to an argument like links, can never be the argument itself in the middle of a debate!
The notion of “Watch this for the next half hour!” is not an argument but a distraction, unless the video is the subject of the thread itself with some relevant text above it. ie: A “soldiers captured/surrendering” video in the Ukraine thread.
It’s therefore important to limit the number of videos posted unless it is absolutely relevant to the topic and argument at hand.
You are the Executive: An obvious abuse of video posting should be condemned by ALL and sundry and failure to condemn it means you approve of this behavior that can lead to forum chaos.
Rule 5: Other, you name and clarify it.
That’s all I’ve got for now.
NB1: The sooner this matter is sorted the sooner we can get back to normality, so ensure you post you feedback/opinion on all this asap.
NB2: Failure to addressing and doing something about the obvious forum problems can only lead to forum failure, and I for one will no longer support the status quo.