Pyrpolizer wrote:Robin Hood wrote:Lordo wrote:The problem is once an idiot is fooled it is hard for them to accept that they were an idiot. Why would anybody join the army unless they had to?
Come on .... be fair! It's a career choice just like any other.
At school when in the last year, I was just 16 and had to make a career choice. I wanted to be an airline pilot but my parents could not afford to pay for that career route so I decided to join the RAF as The Queen had more aero planes than anyone else.
Having signed up as an Apprentice, as I was too young to even think of going to Cranwell, I was working toward that goal but I had a medical at 18 when you sign on for the 12 year career, that showed I had a 'heart 'condition'! So even if I had one of the few that made it that far that put a stop to that long held ambition. I had the option of leaving or going into admin, it was technically know as being 'free as an indulgence'! I left!
My short career path in the RAF showed me just what I explained, that you are conditioned from day 1 that you are one very small part of a massive organisation and your views/opinions count for nothing. You take orders ...... the higher you get the more flexibility you get but no matter how high you get .......YOU ARE UNDER ORDERS.
I had to wait until 1987 to become a private pilot ...... and paid for it all myself ..... ended up with Night/IMC and Twin Rating but it all became far to expensive. but I still have my PPL and have flow in Cyprus a couple of times .... but with an flying instructor in the other seat!
As a relatively free thinker the idea people have to have opinions driven out and replaced with another when they are in the forces ..... is simple common sense and ..... as I said ..... it could not work any other way.
I have this question for you RH. Suppose someone is diagnosed with a slight medical problem, which excludes him from flying passenger planes. Does that exclude him from flying cargo planes as well?
I detect a loaded question? Any notifiable medical condition would preclude you from flying anything .... I would think?
I would however add that ..... my 'heart condition' has never been found in any other medical examination I have had. A month ago I had an MOT and passed with flying colours. Was I 'rejected' because I was not of the class as those that normally are chosen for Cranwell? After all I think Prince William went there .... so it is a POSH establishment! Couldn't have a south \London accented son of a beat Bobby in those posh officer ranks!
To answer your question ..... I don't really know but ..... a medical is a medical. Now if you were to question whether that applied to someone with mental problems still flying an aircraft, I suppose it would be a case of somebody noticing you were mental. When other pilots start refusing to fly with Paphitis because he starts making mistakes and they think he is 'Gung-Ho' and dangerous ........ then he would be put under investigation and re-assessed.
But we all know he is barmy ..... we don't need a shrink to tell us that!