The Best Cyprus Community

Skip to content


Turkish proposal?

How can we solve it? (keep it civilized)

Postby Piratis » Thu Jan 26, 2006 5:22 am

If I was doing what you say (helping Turkish cause etc) you would be silent behind your computer and being very glad for helping your cause. Or you would congratulate me for my opinion.

The fact is my friend that you are pissed off because people like me, the majority of Greek Cypriots, have some dignity and we will fight for our human and democratic rights.

The Turks have killed in Cyprus 100 times more Greek Cypriots than the other way around for a much longer period. Yet people like Lala remember only the 15 years that suits them trying to find excuses for even more crimes against us.

1571 - 1878: More than 300 years of Turkish oppression against Greek Cypriots
1963 - 1974: Crimes of TMT and TC nationalists against Greek Cypriots
1974 - 2006: Ethnic cleansing and illegal occupation of 1/3rd of Cyprus

VS

1963 - 1974: Crimes of EOKA B and GC nationalists against Turkish Cypriots

This is the complete picture my friend, and not the one sided approach that you have.

Regarding population and land ownership here are the official records:

Image

Greek Cypriots have a lot more diaspora by the way. There are 200.000 Greek Cypriots in London alone.

Make up your mind and remember why this agreement is no more, think of a certain Junta who didnt approve, one you dont seem to be able to accept did anything wrong.

Turkey had numerous coups during her lifetime. Does this mean that a foreign country had the right to invade them?

The occupation of Cyprus is as illegal as it gets my friend. You can dream whatever you want but this is the fact. Stop looking for lame excuses to continue your crimes against us.
User avatar
Piratis
Moderator
Moderator
 
Posts: 12261
Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2004 11:08 pm

Postby Viewpoint » Thu Jan 26, 2006 9:11 am

Piratis with your mindset and unflexibile attitude, you are a lost cause its obvious to all you will never negotiate anything, what ever we say falls on deaf ears, whats the point. If you were ever called upon to negotiate god forbid you would empty the room within a matter of seconds. If you havent realized it, its all over for you and the only alternative left is to as you have stated many times wait for that swing in the balance of power that you so long for.
User avatar
Viewpoint
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 25214
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 2:48 pm
Location: Nicosia/Lefkosa

Postby Piratis » Thu Jan 26, 2006 1:26 pm

Viewpoint, do you have any arguments? Or the only think you know is how to make personal attacks? Believe me, I don't care about what you say about me. I know that the cause we are fighting for is just and right because:

1) I am asking for nothing more than democracy and human rights for all, including the respect of the 100% of your human and democratic rights, the way it exists in all other EU countries. (If what I am asking is wrong it would mean all other EU countries have a bad system as well).

2) What I ask for is perfectly aligned with the decisions of the European Court of Human Rights.

3) I do not ask from you to compromise any of your human, democratic, legal or other rights.

4) Your illegal puppet state has been illegal all this time for a reason. All your (and Lalas, Bg_turks etc) arguments seem to be ignoring this fact. Do you realize why your pseudo puppet state is illegal Viewpoint? If you do please tell me, I really want to hear what you think the reason is.

Go ask a British, a French, a German a Turk etc if they would accept what you are asking for their own country. The answer you will get is the same answer I give. Or do you think the Turks would accept to have an Annan plan kind of solution for Turkey were Kurds get the 50% of power and the 30% of land?

What you demand from us is outrageous, it exists nowhere else in the world, it is tailored made to your demands showing no respect even to our basic human and democratic rights and this is why it is rejected by us just like it would be rejected by anybody else for their own country.

For any negotiations to have a result unlike what happened in the past 30 years, you need to change your disrespectful attitude towards us and realize that there is no way we will accept legalization of your crimes against us.

Either there is a solution that respects the human and democratic rights of all Cypriots (win - win) or we remain enemies (loss - loss). What you envision, that you will somehow manage to come victorious out of this by gaining on our loss more than what proportionately belongs to the TC minority, will never happen.

I more than willing to discuss and accommodate your fears as long as this happens within the limits of democracy, human rights and is logical. For example the argument: We have fears thats why we need 30% land for our 18% minority, is baseless. The same goes for many other of your outrageous demands.
As long as what you ask for is not against our human and democratic rights we are more than willing to discuss it. We already accepted Turkish as an official language for example, something that bg_turk admitted that if Turks have been the majority they would never accept have Greek as an official language. We also accept that you can have your own federal state, but in the way federal states are in all federal countries (e.g. USA) and not again in a special way that exists nowhere else and it is tailored on your demands.

We are very flexible. As flexible as anybody from any country with some dignity would be. The problem is with your outrageous demands, not that we obviously can not accept them.
User avatar
Piratis
Moderator
Moderator
 
Posts: 12261
Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2004 11:08 pm

Postby bg_turk » Thu Jan 26, 2006 2:33 pm

Piratis wrote:1) I am asking for nothing more than democracy and human rights for all, including the respect of the 100% of your human and democratic rights, the way it exists in all other EU countries. (If what I am asking is wrong it would mean all other EU countries have a bad system as well).

I am asking for human rights for GC displaced persons within the TRNC as well in accordance with EU principles as well. Why dont you agree?

2) What I ask for is perfectly aligned with the decisions of the European Court of Human Rights.

Including the decision that applying to TRNC can be considered an internal remedy I suppose. The ECHR does not consider the institution of the TRNC illegal, in fact it clearly states that they could be a LEGAL internal remedy if they judge their cases fairly.

4) Your illegal puppet state has been illegal all this time for a reason. All your (and Lalas, Bg_turks etc) arguments seem to be ignoring this fact. Do you realize why your pseudo puppet state is illegal Viewpoint?


Legality without any policing mechanism and a means to enforce it is a meaningless concept. To say the TRNC is illegal is therefore meaningless. To say the TRNC is an unrecognized state is better.
User avatar
bg_turk
Regular Contributor
Regular Contributor
 
Posts: 1172
Joined: Sun Jul 24, 2005 11:24 pm
Location: Bulgaria

Postby Sotos » Thu Jan 26, 2006 3:02 pm

All the Turkish nationalists are attacking Piratis because he asked for democracy and human rights. Am I surprised? No. bg_turk, for the creation of Republic of Cyprus all sides agreed and signed. This is why RoC is legal. The "trnc" was forcefully created against international law and this is why it is illegal. :idea: Everybody knows that except Turkey.
User avatar
Sotos
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 11357
Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2005 2:50 am

Postby bg_turk » Thu Jan 26, 2006 3:15 pm

Sotos,

fine then. Bu then you should really stop your human rights rhetoric, because clearly satisfying your human rights while respecting the current political situation on the island will not be sufficient for you.
You demand the abolition of the TRNC which has nothing to do with human rights, this is a political request, that the TRNC is not obliged to honor.

THe TRNC will continue to exist despite the unfavorable international atmosphere like Kosovo and Taiwan, and will defend itself against any attempt to dismantle it. At the same time the TRNC must honor its obligations under the ECHR and other human rights convention.

The TRNC is not illegal, if it was illegal Jack Straw would not be visiting it and the ECHR would not be recognizing its courts as a LEGAL means of internal remedy.
User avatar
bg_turk
Regular Contributor
Regular Contributor
 
Posts: 1172
Joined: Sun Jul 24, 2005 11:24 pm
Location: Bulgaria

Postby Viewpoint » Thu Jan 26, 2006 3:23 pm

Piratis wrote:Viewpoint, do you have any arguments? Or the only think you know is how to make personal attacks? Believe me, I don't care about what you say about me. I know that the cause we are fighting for is just and right because:

1) I am asking for nothing more than democracy and human rights for all, including the respect of the 100% of your human and democratic rights, the way it exists in all other EU countries. (If what I am asking is wrong it would mean all other EU countries have a bad system as well).

2) What I ask for is perfectly aligned with the decisions of the European Court of Human Rights.

3) I do not ask from you to compromise any of your human, democratic, legal or other rights.

4) Your illegal puppet state has been illegal all this time for a reason. All your (and Lalas, Bg_turks etc) arguments seem to be ignoring this fact. Do you realize why your pseudo puppet state is illegal Viewpoint? If you do please tell me, I really want to hear what you think the reason is.

Go ask a British, a French, a German a Turk etc if they would accept what you are asking for their own country. The answer you will get is the same answer I give. Or do you think the Turks would accept to have an Annan plan kind of solution for Turkey were Kurds get the 50% of power and the 30% of land?

What you demand from us is outrageous, it exists nowhere else in the world, it is tailored made to your demands showing no respect even to our basic human and democratic rights and this is why it is rejected by us just like it would be rejected by anybody else for their own country.

For any negotiations to have a result unlike what happened in the past 30 years, you need to change your disrespectful attitude towards us and realize that there is no way we will accept legalization of your crimes against us.

Either there is a solution that respects the human and democratic rights of all Cypriots (win - win) or we remain enemies (loss - loss). What you envision, that you will somehow manage to come victorious out of this by gaining on our loss more than what proportionately belongs to the TC minority, will never happen.

I more than willing to discuss and accommodate your fears as long as this happens within the limits of democracy, human rights and is logical. For example the argument: We have fears thats why we need 30% land for our 18% minority, is baseless. The same goes for many other of your outrageous demands.
As long as what you ask for is not against our human and democratic rights we are more than willing to discuss it. We already accepted Turkish as an official language for example, something that bg_turk admitted that if Turks have been the majority they would never accept have Greek as an official language. We also accept that you can have your own federal state, but in the way federal states are in all federal countries (e.g. USA) and not again in a special way that exists nowhere else and it is tailored on your demands.

We are very flexible. As flexible as anybody from any country with some dignity would be. The problem is with your outrageous demands, not that we obviously can not accept them.


Piratis you sound like an old broken record and we have argued back and forth our differences many times, we finally agreed that what you envisage which you do not take the time to absorb is not very far from what we are saying and can only be attained via genuine negotiations or war. What you want will not drop out of the sky onto your lap just because you repeat it 50 times a day.

Do you agree on this point? Do you want negotiations or war? It appears to me you would rather wait for the balance of power to swing in your favor which you are free to do but that is not what I want.

Did/do (as you hold onto them so dearly today) we have a 1960 agreements between our 2 communites?

Does any other minority in the world have such partnership agreements?

Do the Kurds have such agreements with Turkey??Do the Pakistanis have such an agreements with the British?

Surely these agreements and the fact that Cyprus also belongs to us as much as you makes us just not any other minority. It in fact makes us your partner, a community whos fears and concerns have to be addressed just like I wish to address yours.

Why are you trying to block this fact out? Tunnelled vision prehaps?
Maybe because it serves your ultimate goal of a Greek Cypriot State?

Your chanting human rights and democracy in every post does not serve a purpose, talk is cheap but administering it and finding a balance is another matter. Your GC style of applying human rights would be to deport a settler who came to this island 30 years, who has buit a life here and has children, is this the human rights you defend in 2006?

We lost the political battle, you convinced the world that the TCs did not want any part of the "RoC" and that we were not necessary to make the "Roc" function thus you reached your goal of a purely GC state and that you respresented all Cypriots. The only snag was you may have left us out of the picture (which we at the time had no problems with as we were busy setting up our own state) but you had lost 1/3 of the island which was now under our control. The idea of not recognizing the North would contradict the idea of reunficiation which the world believed the GCs genuinely desired but as time passes the fact that this was not and is not the case will become more and more evident, who knows what will happen then.
Both sides messed up big time and instead of embracing the 1960 agreements we chose to pursue our hidden agendas to a degree where we divided this island. Being illegal until or if a solution is found does not make me lose sleep at night but having to keep awake to protect my family at night from GC terrorists with the aim to make Cyprus a greek island would.

I do not want human rights and democracy to be administered purely by GCs, there should be a balance to ensure the interest of both communities, is this to much to ask?

The formula to find a solution that both communites can commit to has to be negotiated, otherwise we will be in stalemate for the foreseable future, or until the balance of power swings in your favor.

You and your leadership should concentrate more on working out and putting forward a road map and not objecting to every suggestion that comes along and expect everyone else to sort out our problems.
User avatar
Viewpoint
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 25214
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 2:48 pm
Location: Nicosia/Lefkosa

Postby Sotos » Thu Jan 26, 2006 3:30 pm

bg_turk, even Straw said that his visit is not recognition. He went there to visit the TC leader. The ECHR said that Turkey is responsible for the occupied areas they didn't recognise "trnc". The UN resolution says that "trnc" is legally invalid. If it was legal then why is not recognized even by the countries that support Turkey so much? I agree with piratis that you show no respect to Greek Cypriots. We were pushed out of our homes and Turkey created some state on our land. How could that be legal? It is our country and we never asked or agreed for this state!
User avatar
Sotos
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 11357
Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2005 2:50 am

Postby Sotos » Thu Jan 26, 2006 3:35 pm

Do you want negotiations or war?

Why you didn't negotiate in 1974 instead of invading Cyprus?
User avatar
Sotos
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 11357
Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2005 2:50 am

Postby Sotos » Thu Jan 26, 2006 3:40 pm

but having to keep awake to protect my family at night from GC terrorists with the aim to make Cyprus a greek island would.

:roll: Where did you see the GC terrorists? What I see is 40.000 Turkish troops that occupy Cyprus. The occupation troops are real. Not imaginary like your terrorists. Why you always show GCs as monsters? To say that is correct to harm a monster? No we are not monsters and it is not correct that you harm us and occupy our land!
User avatar
Sotos
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 11357
Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2005 2:50 am

PreviousNext

Return to Cyprus Problem

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests