erolz66 wrote:Sotos wrote:But theoretically speaking in an ideal situation, if there is a uniform, everybody should be in that uniform, otherwise what is the point of the uniform? If we are going to make exceptions to accommodate religions then anybody can wear whatever he/she wants and claim it as something mandated by their religion. Somebody could show up in a Micky Mouse hat and claim that he is a follower of the Micky Mouse religion and that he has to wear it. You can't say that his religion is "made up" and "stupid" because this is the case for all religions, so you can't discriminate against him.
I still do not see why a school uniform policy can not accommodate an appropriate headscarf ? Nor do I think it is beyond the wit of man to be able top say that sikhism is and established recognised religion and mickey mouseism is not ? The school I went to in the UK (private fee paying school - which in some Orwellian way we call a 'public school') had a very strict and strictly enforced uniform policy that was able to accommodate students following religions like sikhism and orthodox judesim without any problem.
Why children should be discriminated based on how established and "recognized" their religion is? The uniform exists to enforce uniformity. If no uniformity is going to be enforced then they might as well abolish the uniform. A relative of mine goes to a private English school where no religious symbols are allowed. There are many children from India, Pakistan, Israel, Arab countries, UK, Russia, EU countries etc (Cypriots are a minority in this school), and all children wear the exact same uniform, no exceptions allowed.
Personally I am against having anything religion related in schools, including the involvement of our own Church which is an obstacle to progress. Progress has been made since the time I was in school, but a lot more needs to be done. I am not against any ethnicity or race, but I am not happy in welcoming to my country religious fanatics. As the example I gave earlier indicates it is not a problem for Muslims, Indians, Hebrew etc NOT to wear such religious symbols. Those who think that such symbols are so important are backward people who I personally do not want in my country and I have no desire to accommodate their backward needs.