The Best Cyprus Community

Skip to content


Collective resolutions for our divided communities

How can we solve it? (keep it civilized)

Postby Viewpoint » Sat Jan 14, 2006 3:13 pm

Keep dreaming and dreaming and dreaming .. like you did for the last 30 years. Partition is illegal, and the results of ethnically cleansing the majority from 1/3rd of Cyprus in order to create an artificial Turkish state will never be legalized.


You leave me no alternative, the choice to jump into the dark GC abis of human rights and democracy applied to minorities in a GC dominated state or dream of recognition, then believe there is really no comparison for myself and many TCs, the later is way ahead and without doubt is what we would chose time and time again. If we are unable to see the elements necessary to protect our community from being dominated by the numerically larger partner in any solution then as you quite rightly have said in the past why bother.
The unrecognized TRNC even in its current state is more than ample for TCs to live peacefully, without discrimination and fear for ones life which we have been doing over the past 32 years.
GC leadership can try to block us at every turn thats been their policy for the last 46 years its nothing new and we are very much accustomed to it. We have coped with it in the past and will do in the future. No one can force us to accept a solution that would ensure that Cyprus becomes as GC dominated state with us as just any other minority.

As for the cleansing of GCs imho over the coming years as there is no solution TCs will take measures that will allow GCs to return and live with us under the TRNC. This will bring a new dimension to the TRNC and the world will evaluate this accordingly. The cogs towards recognition have been turning for many years its only a matter of time when this will come, the choice is now yours a solution that will address all our concerns or stalemate that will produce alternative results. Im willing to wait are you?

When you can't argue against what I say what do you do? You argue against your imagination.
Why do we have this dialog then, if what I say is not what matters? How could any negotiations have any result in this way?


We have to anticipate what your true intentions are as we are all aware where your arguement leads, the majority rules syndrome you support is apparent for all to see. The only thing you do not respond to or chose to ignore is our concerns because you feel it just not worth bothering about which of course suits your agenda of the ultimate GC unitary state.
Its obvious that we are unable to agree on anthing this imo is nothing to do with content of the issues but more to do with both our perceptions of each other which does not allow trust or believe that one community really has the best interests of the other community on a par with their own. Your chanting of GC brand/application of human rights and democracy does not impress anyone and your actions speak louder than anything you can say, just follow what happens to TCs applications in your courts, the selling of TC land, no electricity for TC, no voting rights for TCs, no TC school, objection to meetings with TCs just to name a few, Im sure your 100% behind these actions as you feel it serves your agenda but imo it will work against you and show the world your real intentions.

Suprise us and the world and act democratically and allow TCs their human rights then we can talk about how we can adopt measures to apply those prime examples you so hard fastly apply to all Cypriots. In other words lead by example not by just talking, talk is cheap Piratis.

I am sorry that you can not see that a country were democracy and human rights exists for all, without any kind of discrimination based on race, language, sex etc is for the best of all Cypriots.


Administered by whom???

Please be realistic, we would be at the mercy of the numerically larger GCs. Thanks but no thanks, we have been there and dont want to go back. Your exclusive brand of human rights and democracy causes discrimination and hardship, culminating even in death please allow me the human right to not enter into such an dark abis.

Turkish Cypriots, as the 18%, can have a guaranteed proportional representation in every level, veto powers in all important matters and direct control of anything related to their different culture, religion and language without the involvement of any GC. These are more things than any other minority in the world has, still we do not have any objections since they would not violate our basic human rights.


This part of your post is very positive and encouraging, I apllaud you for it, it shows that deep down you do understand our concerns and that you are willing to discuss them, if you could only get around seeing as wanting to take anything away from you Im sure we could solve matters. The current situation was not created by you or myself but we are left with the very difficult task of clearing up.

Then of course what I say doesn't matter for you, since what it matters is only what you imagine I say, so you can continue your illegalities and crimes. Based on this assumption of yours any dialog and negotiation is rendered useless. It is obvious that what we say will not matter. All you want is a disguised partition, and if you don't get it you will continue with your illegal occupation.


What you say and do are of the utmost importance and it shapes and prompts our own minset and how we respond. So really you contribute to the negativity that comes from the north. If only your leadership realized this and took measures to win over the TCs the whole issue would become more easy to solve but unfortunately that is not the case with you or your leadership. (although the above paragraph does give me a glimmer of hope).
If we cant negotiate a solution then nothing changes and the current status quo continues you have to accept 50% of the responsiblity for this fact.


I just hope that one day TCs will realize there can be no excuse for the violations of the human and democratic rights of people, and that indeed a united federal Cyprus, with no refugees, no human rights violations, equality of all citizens and all the other things that exist in every modern democratic country is the best for Cyprus as well.


When your well being and future are at risk then you have every right. Prove to me this is not the case, and that in a new united Cyprus I will be safe and protected from unjust GC discrimination and feeling just like the other minority in a GC state then I will accept all that you say.

Viewpoint you ask for a tailored made "solution" on your "needs" of having 50% power and 29%+ of land while you are the 18%, and with disregard to our human rights of returning to our own homes and living in a democratic country without any discriminations. I hope you can understand that this can never happen.


The tailor made solution should include all our concerns as in yours and mine and not just mine so dont right off this approach totally as it is the only way forward to address our, yours and our concerns. If there is the trust then the percentages you quote will become irrelevent as all Cypriots will be able to live where ever they wish the borders being superficial and the property issue will be solved by return and compensation but we do not have the trust so that makes ever issue 100 times more difficult to solve. If GCs took concrete steps to build trust and win over the TCs I personally would support them 100% but I cannot see this happening with your current administration.

If you want a solution, stop trying to force on us the outrageous things that exist nowhere else in the world and you have no right for, and simply ask for your rights like we do. Then a solution will be very easy.


If you took the time to listen and absorb what we are saying and spent more time on genuinely trying formulate ways of solving issues rather than oppose all that we say as being outrageous demands then we might move closer to finding a solution.
User avatar
Viewpoint
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 25214
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 2:48 pm
Location: Nicosia/Lefkosa

Postby Kifeas » Sat Jan 14, 2006 4:40 pm

viewpoint wrote:The tailor made solution should include all our concerns as in yours and mine and not just mine so dont right off this approach totally as it is the only way forward to address our, yours and our concerns. If there is the trust then the percentages you quote will become irrelevent as all Cypriots will be able to live where ever they wish the borders being superficial and the property issue will be solved by return and compensation but we do not have the trust so that makes ever issue 100 times more difficult to solve. If GCs took concrete steps to build trust and win over the TCs I personally would support them 100% but I cannot see this happening with your current administration.


Viewpoint, how can we have such a tailor made solution that will include both of our communities concerns, if your concern is how to gain a status which will make each one of you to worth 4 times more than each one of us and also, if your concern is how to make us gift to you our properties so that each one of you will have proportionately 1.5 times more properties that each one of us and also, if your concern is how to make anyone of us to abandon his cultural background and become Turkified if he chooses to live in the 30% of his home country?
User avatar
Kifeas
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 4927
Joined: Fri Mar 18, 2005 10:19 am
Location: Lapithos, Kyrenia, now Pafos; Cyprus.

Postby bg_turk » Sat Jan 14, 2006 5:07 pm

Kifeas wrote:Viewpoint, how can we have such a tailor made solution that will include both of our communities concerns, if your concern is how to gain a status which will make each one of you to worth 4 times more than each one of us and also, if your concern is how to make us gift to you our properties so that each one of you will have proportionately 1.5 times more properties that each one of us and also, if your concern is how to make anyone of us to abandon his cultural background and become Turkified if he chooses to live in the 30% of his home country?


I have always argued that minorites are very vulnerable to assimilation and you have always dismissed those arguments as ridiculous. Now I see you are using essentially the same argument in order to discourage people from accepting a solution in which greek cypriots will be citizens of the TRNC. This is a double standart.
What makes you think that GCs will be turkified if they become citizens of the TRNC, and TC will NOT be grekified if they become citizens of the RoC?
User avatar
bg_turk
Regular Contributor
Regular Contributor
 
Posts: 1172
Joined: Sun Jul 24, 2005 11:24 pm
Location: Bulgaria

Postby Viewpoint » Sat Jan 14, 2006 6:07 pm

bg_turk wrote:
Kifeas wrote:Viewpoint, how can we have such a tailor made solution that will include both of our communities concerns, if your concern is how to gain a status which will make each one of you to worth 4 times more than each one of us and also, if your concern is how to make us gift to you our properties so that each one of you will have proportionately 1.5 times more properties that each one of us and also, if your concern is how to make anyone of us to abandon his cultural background and become Turkified if he chooses to live in the 30% of his home country?


I have always argued that minorites are very vulnerable to assimilation and you have always dismissed those arguments as ridiculous. Now I see you are using essentially the same argument in order to discourage people from accepting a solution in which greek cypriots will be citizens of the TRNC. This is a double standart.
What makes you think that GCs will be turkified if they become citizens of the TRNC, and TC will NOT be grekified if they become citizens of the RoC?


bg-turk, Kifeas bends with the wind as it suits his arguements. But TCs want to address GC concerns as well Kifeas, for example Kifeas your property, you should be paid full market compensation because as far as I know from what you have said its beyond the point of return because villas have been built upon it. I know you will argue that you want your ancestral home back but we dont have a magic wand to wave and we have to deal with what we have in front of us. Then with full compensation you can buy something equivelent where ever you wish. As for a TC being worth more than a GC i am all for a balance where TCs could intervene when the issue actually effects TCs more adversely than GCs or issues which have been determined during a solution. Why dont you try to workout a formula where TCs will not be left at the mercy of GCs domination and discrimination, put yourself in our shoes and put something that would be acceptable to you as a TC this issue is high on the list of proiorities for TCs.
User avatar
Viewpoint
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 25214
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 2:48 pm
Location: Nicosia/Lefkosa

Postby Kifeas » Sat Jan 14, 2006 6:48 pm

Viewpoint wrote:
Kifeas wrote:Viewpoint, how can we have such a tailor made solution that will include both of our communities concerns, if your concern is how to gain a status which will make each one of you to worth 4 times more than each one of us and also, if your concern is how to make us gift to you our properties so that each one of you will have proportionately 1.5 times more properties that each one of us and also, if your concern is how to make anyone of us to abandon his cultural background and become Turkified if he chooses to live in the 30% of his home country?


TCs want to address GC concerns as well Kifeas, for example Kifeas your property, you should be paid full market compensation because as far as I know from what you have said its beyond the point of return because villas have been built upon it. I know you will argue that you want your ancestral home back but we dont have a magic wand to wave and we have to deal with what we have in front of us. Then with full compensation you can buy something equivelent where ever you wish. As for a TC being worth more than a GC i am all for a balance where TCs could intervene when the issue actually effects TCs more adversely than GCs or issues which have been determined during a solution. Why dont you try to workout a formula where TCs will not be left at the mercy of GCs domination and discrimination, put yourself in our shoes and put something that would be acceptable to you as a TC this issue is high on the list of proiorities for TCs.


Viewpoint,
1. I did not speak specifically about my property. Live my individual case out of the discussion!
2. Were you going to get through the A-plan -as members of the TC community and on the on the aggregate, 1.5 times more property per individual -area wise, than the GCs would be left out with per individual, and 2 times more property per individual -value wise, than the GCs would be left out with per individual? Yes or no? The answer is yes! Why?
3. In the A-plan, would any GC that have gone to live in the north state, need to become Turkified in order to become a citizen of the north 29% of his homeland? Ye or no? The answer is yes! Why?
4. In the A-plan, would every member of the TC community have 4 times more opportunities (higher probability) to become a member of the senate, 3 times more opportunities to become a member of the federal government and 3 times more opportunities to become an employee of the federal government, than every member of the GC community? Yes or no? The answer is yes! Why?
5. You always speak about compensation. I do not want your compensation! If everything was a matter of compensation (money,) we could as well have suggested to you to compensate you instead, and then go to live in another country. I want my fair share as an individual human being and as an equal citizen of this country! You instead want a solution that will reduce me to something less than an equal individual, in comparison to you. Why? Is it because you are a Turk and consequently you feel that as an individual you must worth more than I do?
User avatar
Kifeas
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 4927
Joined: Fri Mar 18, 2005 10:19 am
Location: Lapithos, Kyrenia, now Pafos; Cyprus.

Postby Piratis » Sun Jan 15, 2006 8:53 am

Viewpoint, if partition is what you want (which apparently is) then you should stop trying to disguise this partition to make it sound nice.

I already told you that there are many ways to safeguard both communities without disrespecting the human rights of anybody and by having a democracy were all citizens are equal without racial discrimination. (The safeguards are: guaranteed proportional representation at all levels, veto powers on important matters, direct control of the things that give TCs their unique identity - religion, language, etc). I also accepted that TCs can have 18% of land as their own federal state with the same power that US states have.

Now these are more than any other minority in the world has, but as long as there are not violations of our human and democratic rights I have no problem.

Beyond that you have no right to ask for anything more. If you still don't trust Greek Cypriots, the residents of the whole island for 3500 years you have only one legal option: move out of Cyprus.

You have no right to demand the human and democratic rights violations of Greek Cypriots because you supposedly feel unsafe. It is like asking for banning everybody else from driving so you can feel more safe driving in the street.
And don't selectively bring me the 1% of history as an excuse now by forgetting the other 99%.

Now I see you are using essentially the same argument in order to discourage people from accepting a solution in which greek cypriots will be citizens of the TRNC. This is a double standart.

No.
1) The T in "TRNC" stands for Turkish. RoC is not a Greek island. it is a Cypriot island.
2) RoC was not created by ethnically cleansing others from Cyprus. the "TRNC" was illegally forced by Turkey in Cyprus against the wish and the human and legal rights of the majority of the population.
User avatar
Piratis
Moderator
Moderator
 
Posts: 12261
Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2004 11:08 pm

Postby Piratis » Sun Jan 15, 2006 8:58 am

Is any of what I say imagined or untrue? Isn't what you want a unitary state?
I know your arguments very well by the way. I have been arguing with you for more than half a year now!

Yes, I want a unitary state - true.
Yes, I compromise for a BBF (as described in my previous posts) - true.

Apparently you have difficulty to understand this, since compromising is something unknown to you. The only thing you know how to "compromise" are illegal demands.
User avatar
Piratis
Moderator
Moderator
 
Posts: 12261
Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2004 11:08 pm

Postby Viewpoint » Sun Jan 15, 2006 4:05 pm

Kifeas
1. I did not speak specifically about my property. Live my individual case out of the discussion!


I just wanted to provide the example of properties like yours where development is on such a large scale that it cannot be reversed the full market value or an equivelent property of TC of same value should be offered to individulas in your situation. I apologise if this purely innocent reference has caused you to become upset.

2. Were you going to get through the A-plan -as members of the TC community and on the on the aggregate, 1.5 times more property per individual -area wise, than the GCs would be left out with per individual, and 2 times more property per individual -value wise, than the GCs would be left out with per individual? Yes or no? The answer is yes! Why?
3. In the A-plan, would any GC that have gone to live in the north state, need to become Turkified in order to become a citizen of the north 29% of his homeland? Ye or no? The answer is yes! Why?
4. In the A-plan, would every member of the TC community have 4 times more opportunities (higher probability) to become a member of the senate, 3 times more opportunities to become a member of the federal government and 3 times more opportunities to become an employee of the federal government, than every member of the GC community? Yes or no? The answer is yes! Why?


I could argue the pros and cons but obviously the Annan plan was not acceptable to GCs who resoundingly rejected it. Its over and theres nothing on the table any more or even brewing, so constantly making excuses does not serve any purpose other then to elivate your desire to explain away your rejection of this comprehensive solution. Well get over it, we have and the only thing thats left is the nasty after taste which is in every TC subconsious for future reference.

5. You always speak about compensation. I do not want your compensation! If everything was a matter of compensation (money,) we could as well have suggested to you to compensate you instead, and then go to live in another country. I want my fair share as an individual human being and as an equal citizen of this country! You instead want a solution that will reduce me to something less than an equal individual, in comparison to you. Why? Is it because you are a Turk and consequently you feel that as an individual you must worth more than I do?


look Kifeas get it in your head we are not going anywhere off this island GCs like you and Piratis always recommend this to us because it is clearly your desire and ultimate goal. We TCs never recommend this to you, because we truly believe this island belongs to us all and that if we cannot live together in harmony then its best we live apart.

If compenstaion is not the solution to those that cannot have their property rights returned then what do you suggest? Knocking down a 10million hotel? or luxury development of 20 holiday homes?

All prople are equal and I do not evaluate people in the sense that you are suggesting but if a balance has to be struck to ensure GCs do not dominate discriminate and persecute TCs (so in your own words they can go live elsewhere) in their own country then I am all for any measures that will ensure that this does not occur.
I do not trust or can stomach the notion of Cyprus being run by GCs and their twisted brand of human rights and democracy whereby at every turn they would be attempting to erode and assimilate TCs into the numerically larger GC community. You are not blind yet you choose not to see our concerns and you every attempt reeks of attempts to achieve a Greek state with TCs as any other minority in the world, its high time that you realized TC will not return to any secenario where there is evidence of this and the measure we seek are not adopted. Maybe you should spend more time on how do we achieve this? and less time on trying to reduce us to a minority status.
User avatar
Viewpoint
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 25214
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 2:48 pm
Location: Nicosia/Lefkosa

Postby Viewpoint » Sun Jan 15, 2006 5:53 pm

Piratis let me see if you have taken any notice of what I have been saying over the months od conversation we have been having, why do i support recognized partiton?

I already told you that there are many ways to safeguard both communities without disrespecting the human rights of anybody and by having a democracy were all citizens are equal without racial discrimination. (The safeguards are: guaranteed proportional representation at all levels, veto powers on important matters, direct control of the things that give TCs their unique identity - religion, language, etc). I also accepted that TCs can have 18% of land as their own federal state with the same power that US states have.

Now these are more than any other minority in the world has, but as long as there are not violations of our human and democratic rights I have no problem.


In principle I agree with you but you have to take into account we are not just like any other country we have our own unique history, culture, fears and concerns and therefore have to incorporate elements to ensure compliance and deterrants.
What you convey is that your ultimate goal is a unitary state where we are just reduced from having our own country (be it unrecognized) to a minority in a GCs run Greek state which administers its own twisted brand of human rights and democracy,can you understand why this idea sickens us and is not desirable, we will never go back to being second class and discriminated against in our own country, noway.

Beyond that you have no right to ask for anything more. If you still don't trust Greek Cypriots, the residents of the whole island for 3500 years you have only one legal option: move out of Cyprus.


This is exactly the attiude we hate and fear, your mentality is clear and evident for all to see and read. You have no right to say i cannot ask is that the GC human rights and emocracy i would have to face in a united Cyprus?

You have no right to demand the human and democratic rights violations of Greek Cypriots because you supposedly feel unsafe. It is like asking for banning everybody else from driving so you can feel more safe driving in the street.
And don't selectively bring me the 1% of history as an excuse now by forgetting the other 99%.


So I have no rights in your GC brand of human rights and democracy to take the necessary measures to ensure I do not get knocked down or that drivers stop at red lights or are imprisoned if they run me down. I think I have every right to protect my community and ensure that no harm comes to them and thats why I demand rules and regulations should be put in place to make sure that we do not make the mistakes of the past and that GCs do not dominate TCs.
User avatar
Viewpoint
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 25214
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 2:48 pm
Location: Nicosia/Lefkosa

Postby Viewpoint » Sun Jan 15, 2006 6:50 pm

This is the Piratis brand of human rights and democracy in 2006 that he is so proud of and chants at every opportunity, thanks but no thanks,

Koursoumba, who is also the President of the National Institution for the Protection of Human Rights (ETHNOPAD), said that she wondered, “how the authorities can keep on doing this. It is a matter that is simply not going away. I have tried to speak to the authorities but have not yet received a satisfactory response.”

She added that, “by January 26, we must harmonise our laws with the rest of Europe in relation to third country nationals who have been resident in Cyprus for over five years. These people cannot just be kicked out of the country. Humanitarian law doesn’t work like this – human rights are the cornerstone of all fields of the law.

“When looking at whether a person should be deported, it is very important to consider a variety of factors, for example whether that person has children and what their rights are. We keep forgetting about human rights, as set out by the UN, and must adhere to the treaties that we have signed.



Quote out of one of todays articles in the Sunday Mail. Practice what you preach Piratis as i said before talk is cheap. Backs up my arguement about settlers and throws light on how we should deal with them. A man who has lived on this island for 30 years deserves treated with full human rights and democracy but not GC style.
User avatar
Viewpoint
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 25214
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 2:48 pm
Location: Nicosia/Lefkosa

PreviousNext

Return to Cyprus Problem

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest