STUD:
You seem to suggest the Nazis only turned against the Jews in 1933, following the boycott, when you do not address the issue of why Jews were boycotting German business.
As far as historical reports suggest, the Jews did ‘
offically’ turn against the Germans in 1933 and declared economic war because the Germans had previously boycotted their businesses and Jews were no longer ‘
welcome’ in the civil service after the Versailles Treaty in 1917. This was more due to the reparations that Germany suffered as a consequence, which caused an economic collapse and the Germans blamed the Jews.
Then the Germans turned on the Jews economically, with obviously incidents of violence but this was not an orchestrated campaign of violence until later. (
We see the same thing today with Islamaphobia.) I think there is good reason to believe that maybe they were a bit miffed?
The Germans had no concentration camps at that time but were no doubt economically retaliating against the Jews for their perceived treachery, when of course it was Zionists that were responsible rather than Jews. The same treaty led to the formation of the Nazi’s under Hitler in 1920.
Was it perhaps because of the known Anti Semitism of the Nazi Party from 1920, some 13. years before the agreement, as exemplified by the party leader's writings in "Mein Kampf" , dating from 1923 ' ten years before the agreement, and where it was no doubt clear from January 1933, what was developing and likely to develop in Germany, as evidenced by the actuality of events from 1933 onwards?
Nobody could have seen the Holocaust coming ........ that would be beyond any credible preconception! But the Nazi’s were not in power until 1933! Surely, up to that point, the ramblings of somebody who was inherently anti-Semitic would not have been of real significance until the Nazi’s came into power, any more than similar anti-Semitic rants from extreme Nationalist organisations in the UK at the time,(
Mosely?) or indeed people like Marin Le Pen today? Even in 1933 I don’t think there was an indication that the Nazi’s wanted to exterminate the Jews, maybe they wanted to get rid of them out of Germany, that cannot be denied but mass murder was not the order of the day.
Neither were in the agreement to help the other: the Zionists wanted to help their people out.
IMO: Not really true as the Zionists intent in this jointly beneficial arrangement was to
ensure the Jews moved to Palestine and very few of them were interested. Most would rather have gone to the US or UK but that was blocked and not by the Germans! By seeming to be complicit in some way with the Nazi’s by tolerating Jewish persecution, the Zionists were ensuring that those subjected to this anti-Semitism would be more likely to move to the ME rather than remain in Germany. The extermination camps came into being in the 1940’s and there is no excuse for what the Nazi’s did after that time.
The Germans regarded the Jews as a threat to their national security as the Jews (
or rather Zionists?) had declared war on Germany when they announced solidarity with Germany’s enemy ..... the UK, in 1939. The original concept was internment rather than extermination ..... that idea was dreamed up later by the Nazi’s led by Himmler and his followers ......... as their ‘
Final Solution’. Initially the intent was little different than the way the US saw the same threat when war was declared against Japan, they interned ALL those with Japanese ancestry as a similar threat. There the similarity ends.
The Germans saw it as a way of solving their perceived Jewish problem and making money.
I think more a case of solving their problem than financial return? The Zionists and the Nazi’s both wanted the same thing but for different reasons. A feeling of anti-Semitism was beneficial for both of them.
In my view we have to look at history to determine why the Holocaust took place. You can see today, that any criticism of Israel’s actions are immediately jumped on as being ant-Semitic and yet it is common knowledge, even within Israel, that the Zionist led Government under Netanyahu is heading in the same direction as the Nazi’s. Gaza is a much bigger concentration camp than ANY of the Nazi ones ......... the only thing absent is the gas chambers and the ovens!
But we are not allowed to say so and not allowed by law to boycott Israeli goods from the occupied lands. The press, which is to a great extent controlled by Zionists, rarely tells a story that is antithetical to Israel’s interests, when such events are released in the independent press it is inevitably condemned as propaganda. In addition, the Israeli’s have a string of UN resolutions condemning what they are doing but this never converts to action. Maybe in 5-10 years time we will see the Israeli Leadership and their Zionist supporters in the US/UK in a modern version of the Nurnberg Tribunals ..... although I somehow doubt it!