CBBB:
I seem to have seen this (argument) somewhere else, ProVox.
Yes CBBB you have but as you can see the majority of people do not understand the concept that commercial banks produce 97-98% of ‘money’ in circulation........... out of thin air! It is something of interest to me and you never know one day the message will get through? It is a concept difficult to accept but once the penny drops it is very apparent that this is the only way new money is created and a much clearer picture of events in Greece become apparent. IMO: Tsipras and Varoufakis have a good grasp of the concept.
The German finance Minister summed it up when he told Tsipras that “The 'common people' would not understand the problem and therefore their referendum was irrelevant”. He is right ..... they don’t understand.
SOROS:
Commercial banks cannot create money. In EU this can be done only by ECB. "Printing" money can increase inflation and devaluate the currency. When a country can print its own money then it can choose the optimal balance between how much money they created vs inflation and the valuation of their currency. The problem with EU is that the ideal balance between those factors is different for each country.
I am sorry SOROS but you are wrong! What you are referring to is ‘note-and-coin’ which indeed is printed only by the European Central Bank as is the case for any currency. But this represents about ~3% of the money in circulation, the other ~97% is created by commercial banks as debt. This printed money the ECB shipped to Cyprus and now to Greece because without it the banks do not have enough money to service their debts ...... i.e. the money they borrow from you when you pay money into the bank. If the bank goes down, you are an unsecured creditor, simply because the banks have
nothing in the way of collateral to back the money they create. If you or I tried it we would end up serving time!
The money created by the commercial banks is always created as a debt whereas a sovereign currency produced by a government via an independent Central Bank as note and coin, or electronically, is spent into circulation and is a) Free of debt; b) Free of interest; c) continually circulates. Mind you this is not something the Bankers like very much as they prefer the current debt based (debt slavery) economies out of which they make their billions.
The problem with EU is that the ideal balance between those factors is different for each country.
Which is why the Eurozone can never work unless the richer countries are prepared to subsidise the poorer countries .... which they obviously are not!
It is an involved subject and far too long to discus on here.