erolz66 wrote:Tim Drayton wrote:I fully agree that every attempt at "Communism" has so far ended in disaster, and I speak as somebody who witnessed the horrors of marshal-law Poland as a student in Warsaw in 1983-1984. However, I still prefer to believe that a better society is possible, whether you term it "Communism" or something else. I find the Rojava experiment in a decentralised form of socialism with the maximum possible amount of local autonomy interesting. I live in hope that one day humanity will find a way of creating a just society. I certainly don't see much justice in neo-liberal globalised capitalism under which a handful of people are increasingly dominating the world.
Well said.
I think there is some evidence that actually China today is abandoning dogma and is actually doing some potentially interesting stuff based on an administrative 'class' that gets its legitimacy from its people not through 'democracy' but simply through 'what works' in terms of delivering better lives for those that live there. A kind of 'marketplace' of 'government', where what works is replicated and those who design and implement what works, promoted and move up and through the administrative class and what fails is rejected. It is very early days but I think there is a real chance that China will be at the forefront of finding a 'new way' that actually is better than neo-liberal globalised capitalism we have today.
China has embraced the free market and that has improved the lives of millions. But there is also a lot of poverty still.
They also lack democracy.
You need to prove that Western Countries are less fair than in countries such as China. In many EU countries, UK, Australia, Canada you have universal health care. In China, if you fall sick, you simply die. The only western country that has both botched it up so to speak is USA.
There are a lot of problems in China, there is a reason why Hong Kong wants to elect its own leaders and to be semi autonomous. Sure, the free market is improving things but it will be a very long time before China even gets close to other countries. They are progressing economically but not politically.