Kikapu wrote:Paphitis wrote:
As gory as it may sound, the innocent passengers would not be a factor. They could all be American Citizens but it would not matter. How can they justify that? Very easily when they will claim that their action was necessary to protect the lives of many more on the ground. And there isn't much of a argument against this, certainly no legal one that is for sure.
The Chinese in particular are very draconian about their ADIZ and wouldn't hesitate. The political cost would exist, but the Department of Defence will issue an official statement and after a few days or weeks, it is all forgotten. They may offer the families some financial assistance and they will express deep sorrow, but really there is not much else that can be done.
That's all very well if the unidentified plane was approaching New York from the Atlantic, but according to you, Diego Garcia has very little importance to warrant shooting down anything, let alone a large jetliner, therefore political fallout will be much greater if such an act occurred.
I never said that Diego Garcia is not important. it is as important to other bases and there are 200 permanent service personnel and 2000 contractors that work there.
Strategically however, it is not one of the important bases. For instance, it is not as important as Akrotiri in Cyprus.
They probably would shoot it down only if they were satisfied that MH370 was going to kill people on the ground. The commander or his chain of command will weigh many things up. Are any service personnel at risk of being killed? That is the type of question that will trigger a harsh response.
Losing the runway, or a hangar temporarily or even a couple of aircraft may not do so automatically. They could just be happy to take the hit.
Losing the JETA1 Fuel Facility might be another factor considering the fact that Diego Garcia's main importance is as a fuel stop for military aircraft between Australia and Europe.