supporttheunderdog wrote:Gods and religion are both man made. Gods first appeared as an anthropomorphic personification of natural phenomena that early man (I will not use the phrase primitive) could not understand, so we had eg weather gods and fertility gods, etc. Now we know more, through science,
Religion was the codification of belief, frequently to the benefit of power holders who claimed a relationship with the gods or god, and who promoted themselves as the representatives of the gods on Earth, which gave them authority to rule: an offence against them was an offence against god. See eg what happens in Iran today.
There might be some creator, who one might call a god, but I very much doubt that if it exists, it, whatever characteristics it might have, will be anything like that described in any religious books, like the Bible or Koran as the god of those books is a human invention.
I agree entirely.
Religion may have offered to those in need comfort and hope and I fully understand this "need".
Some years back whilst visiting a Temple in Sri Lanka with my then Doctor and friend who knew my views on religion, he pointed at the numerous devotees dressed mostly in rugs and obviously very poor and asked me.
John he said, take away religion from these people and what would they be left with ?
Having faced my own hour of need that lasted 8 years I'm content that neither I nor my late wife pursued refuge, hope and comfort from a man made fantasy, BOTH OF US HAD SEEN THE LIGHT.
Can I also mention that millions of children derive extreme pleasure anticipating Father Christmas arrival.Therefore I would not take away FC from these children anymore that I would attempt to take God away from those in need.
May their ...peaceful God be with them.