Vassos1 wrote:Birkibrisli: I am afraid that, as you may have said; my reasons for wanting two-republic states differ greatly from the reasons of your Turkish brothers on Northern Cyprus and Turkey. Although I think that Cyprus would be better off by accepting the realities of two very distinct peoples on the island, I still believe that the Turkish Cypriots are very lucky that we have accepted them after the overwhelming support that they had shown to the Turkish Army in the invasion of 1974. Even my Turkish Cypriot next door neighbours held their guns towards us when we were being forced to leave our homes by UN guardsman. My trust has never been the same. I am sorry.
Vassos,
1.) I am reading your postings occasionally. I have come to the conclusion that the reasons behind your ideas and suggestions have nothing to do with the indeed frustrating “insolvability” of the Cyprus problem within the given and current parameters of re-unification through a federation, but mainly because (a) deep inside you, you maintain feelings of resentment towards the TCs and (b) because you aspire an “ethnically” pure Greek Cypriot RoC, mainly for nationalistic sentiments.
2.) I have come to this conclusion simply because I noticed that -once your whatever logical arguments in support of your proposals run short, you retrieve into arguments like the above quoted reply to Birkibrisli.
3.) You said above that the reasons behind your wanting of two separate states, differ greatly from the reasons that presumably the TCs want them (although I am confident that this is not necessarily the case anymore -at least with the majority of the TCs.) However, at the same time you speak about the reality of two distinct people in Cyprus, exactly in the same way that Denktash and the other Turkish /TC chauvinists used to make use of it. You have to decide, do you subscribe to the Denktash doctrine of two distinct people on the island, or not? Depending on your -in no uncertain terms- reply to this question, I will then proceed –if you wish so- to further discuss this particular issue with you.
4.) Like you -although a bit younger, I was caught in the middle of the war zone (invasion) in 1974 and I have experienced and seen a lot. Like you, I have lost close relatives, very valuable properties, all my childhood memories but more importantly, I lost contact with what defines my historical identity as a Greek speaking Cypriot. Things for which I have not come into terms with, and I will never come as long as I live and the present situation continues.
5.) You seem to be bothered with the fact that the TC community assisted the Turkish invading forces in 1974, in their pursued to partition the island. I am bothered too. I am even more bothered knowing that the Turkish invasion, as things stood then, would have never succeeded if there wasn’t this internal help by the TC community. However, I am twice more bothered knowing that -even with the given TC assistance- the Turkish invasion would have still never succeeded if we did not dissolve our entire defence mechanisms with our own hands and as a result of the coup. You seem to have no words to say about this later reality. Why? Why do you emphasise on the role of the TCs only? What about the role of some GCs during those events? Aren’t you bothered that these people circulate freely among us during all these years and they also engage in politics, try to have a say and a role in our affairs? Why you are only bothered about the TCs?
6.) You are bothered by the role of the TCs in the 1974 events. Have you ever wondered what pushed the majority of the TCs into such a role? Was the fact that the TCs were preparing and longing for a Turkish invasion long before it happened, a totally unknown fact for us then? No it wasn’t! Have you ever wondered why a community that used to be living among us for 300 years, spoke our language, worked and lived together with us in the same jobs, fields, villages and towns, attended and enjoyed each others company, holiday celebrations, weddings, played sports in the same teams and all the rest, would all of suddenly and within just one decade would want to completely separate themselves from us and divide the island? Is this normal? Have you ever wondered what our responsibility was so that almost the TC community took such a path? Have you ever wondered what our side did and more importantly what we did not do, either because of neglect or indifference, so that such an outcome did not materialise? Weren’t we the ones who were the most “content” (together with the TC chauvinists) for the situation in which the entire TC community found itself before 1974? Weren’t we the ones who were whistling indifferent for the fact that the TC community remained enclave and impoverished in their “strongholds” and thus a total and complete pray to their chauvinist and pro-partition leadership and the TMT, and thus allowed to be convinced that their “salvation” would only come through a Turkish invasion and partition of Cyprus? What did we do, or better what we did not do, in order to put an end to this dangerous for all of us reality? There were many things we could have done, but instead we were wasting all our energy and thoughts in fighting each other internally, with some of us undermining the state and some others wasting their time and energy in order to figure out how to confront the underminers.
7.) You are bothered that your TC neighbours turned up their guns to your family in 1974. I am sure this is a fact, and you are right to be bothered. I will also add that many GCs were in fact murdered by TCs during 1974, after their arrest by the Turkish troops. What you are forgetting however, is the fact that at the same time many TC civilians (women, children and elders) were also murdered by the Eoka B fascist criminals, who instead of going to Kyrenia to fight the Turkish invading forces, they had chosen to play the safe game of arresting entire TC villages and in many cases in which those arrests were not registered and recorded by the red cross, they exploited the chaos of the invasion in order to proceed to mass murders. Are you aware that at least as many as 500 TC innocent civilians -a number which percentage wise is almost as high as the GC losses, were murdered in this way, many of which were originating from the villages that are situated in the region from which you are coming from? Are any of your relatives by any chance related to those murderers? If yes then this would possibly explain your fears and dislike of the idea that the two communities come back and live together.
8.) Nevertheless, what you are definately “forgetting” -because it obviously does not suit your theories, is the fact that perhaps as many GCs were saved from the Turkish /TC chauvinists as a result of last minute intervention by other TCs, in the same way of course that as many or even more TCs were saved from the hands of the Eoka B chauvinists by other GCs. If you happen to meet any GC from the Afania village (a village that used to be mixed before 1974,) ask him to explain to you how they were saved by a TC young officer originating from the same village and was acting as a guide to the Turkish troops during the second phase. The young TC, after having seen what happened to the GCs of the nearby GC village once the Turkish troops raided in, deserted from his duties as a guide and risking his own life (which he eventually lost during his return) run ahead of the Turkish battalion in order to reach his village first and inform his GC go-villagers to evacuate it as soon as possible, before the Turkish troops arrive. The TC inhabitants of this village (Afania) not only did not forget their GC co-villagers during the last 30 years, but when the “boarders” re-opened in 2003, they cleaned their church, cemetery, painted their houses, etc, invited them to visit the village collectively and they staged a day-long festival in the middle of the village with music, dances and food to celebrate their re-union. Now, I suggest to you to go and try to sell your ideas to the people -GCs and TCs alike, of this village. And this is just one of the numerous (almost uncounted) examples and cases that took place both in the north and in the south, during the last 2.5 years. This is the untold history of Cyprus!
9.) Have you ever wondered how much poorer and plain our lives could /would be if loosing the TC element from our culture and society? Have you ever wondered what we will be telling our visitors - tourists from other European countries, but more importantly to our children in 30 or 50 years from now, when they will be pointing at the mosques, cemeteries and the other TC monuments in the south and asking us who these things belong to, what happened to those people and why they are not here any more? Are we going to destroy them too, in a similar way that the chauvinists in the north attempted to do, so that we erase the evidence of the existence -once- of a different culture to ours? Or are we going to say to our children that we let those people go away because we were both too primitive to accept to live together in one country? Will they forgive us for giving up and not trying until the very end?