The Best Cyprus Community

Skip to content


The Cyprus problem is a relic of the Cold War

How can we solve it? (keep it civilized)

Postby insan » Sun Oct 17, 2010 7:11 pm

wyoming cowboy wrote:sure it can but the tc and turkey are using the argument that it was an ethnic conflict which it wasnt, Cyprus has not used the cold war argument and keeps falling into the turk trap that a bizonal federation is needed to preserve the survival of the tc......if the cold war argument is used more effectively then the occupation of Cyprus becomes as antiquated as the Berlin Wall.


So, what about Cretan and Rhodesian Turks that had no chance to "create a problem" and most of them had to left the islands they inhabitted for 100s of years?

Why didn't the cold war affect the strategically important island Crete or Rhodes and cause a conflict there similar to Cyprus problem?
User avatar
insan
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 9044
Joined: Mon Jun 30, 2003 11:33 pm
Location: Somewhere in ur network. ;]

Postby kurupetos » Sun Oct 17, 2010 8:43 pm

humanist wrote:Cyprus is a great place and we need to Unite to make it better.


No we don't. We just need to take out the trash. :wink:
User avatar
kurupetos
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 18855
Joined: Tue Jul 31, 2007 7:46 pm
Location: Cyprus

Postby wyoming cowboy » Sun Oct 17, 2010 9:28 pm

insan wrote:
wyoming cowboy wrote:sure it can but the tc and turkey are using the argument that it was an ethnic conflict which it wasnt, Cyprus has not used the cold war argument and keeps falling into the turk trap that a bizonal federation is needed to preserve the survival of the tc......if the cold war argument is used more effectively then the occupation of Cyprus becomes as antiquated as the Berlin Wall.


So, what about Cretan and Rhodesian Turks that had no chance to "create a problem" and most of them had to left the islands they inhabitted for 100s of years?

Why didn't the cold war affect the strategically important island Crete or Rhodes and cause a conflict there similar to Cyprus problem?


because Cyprus was not part of nato like crete and rhodes in the 1960's
User avatar
wyoming cowboy
Regular Contributor
Regular Contributor
 
Posts: 1756
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2008 2:15 am

Postby Oracle » Sun Oct 17, 2010 9:46 pm

insan wrote:
wyoming cowboy wrote:sure it can but the tc and turkey are using the argument that it was an ethnic conflict which it wasnt, Cyprus has not used the cold war argument and keeps falling into the turk trap that a bizonal federation is needed to preserve the survival of the tc......if the cold war argument is used more effectively then the occupation of Cyprus becomes as antiquated as the Berlin Wall.


So, what about Cretan and Rhodesian Turks that had no chance to "create a problem" and most of them had to left the islands they inhabitted for 100s of years?

Why didn't the cold war affect the strategically important island Crete or Rhodes and cause a conflict there similar to Cyprus problem?


There are still many Turks in Rhodes. As for Crete, they left for Turkey. Nice decision!
User avatar
Oracle
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 23507
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2008 11:13 am
Location: Anywhere but...

Postby insan » Sun Oct 17, 2010 9:46 pm

wyoming cowboy wrote:
insan wrote:
wyoming cowboy wrote:sure it can but the tc and turkey are using the argument that it was an ethnic conflict which it wasnt, Cyprus has not used the cold war argument and keeps falling into the turk trap that a bizonal federation is needed to preserve the survival of the tc......if the cold war argument is used more effectively then the occupation of Cyprus becomes as antiquated as the Berlin Wall.


So, what about Cretan and Rhodesian Turks that had no chance to "create a problem" and most of them had to left the islands they inhabitted for 100s of years?

Why didn't the cold war affect the strategically important island Crete or Rhodes and cause a conflict there similar to Cyprus problem?


because Cyprus was not part of nato like crete and rhodes in the 1960's


:?
User avatar
insan
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 9044
Joined: Mon Jun 30, 2003 11:33 pm
Location: Somewhere in ur network. ;]

Postby insan » Sun Oct 17, 2010 9:57 pm

Oracle wrote:
insan wrote:
wyoming cowboy wrote:sure it can but the tc and turkey are using the argument that it was an ethnic conflict which it wasnt, Cyprus has not used the cold war argument and keeps falling into the turk trap that a bizonal federation is needed to preserve the survival of the tc......if the cold war argument is used more effectively then the occupation of Cyprus becomes as antiquated as the Berlin Wall.


So, what about Cretan and Rhodesian Turks that had no chance to "create a problem" and most of them had to left the islands they inhabitted for 100s of years?

Why didn't the cold war affect the strategically important island Crete or Rhodes and cause a conflict there similar to Cyprus problem?


There are still many Turks in Rhodes. As for Crete, they left for Turkey. Nice decision!


The Land Forces on Crete 1897/98

Crete (Greek: Kriti, Turkish: Kirid, Italian: Candia) one of the largest islands in the Mediterranean Sea was in the last half of the 19th century an area of permanent troubles. The majority of inhabitants were of the Christian religion and rebelled against the Muslim minority which was supported by the local Ottoman government. After the great mutiny in 1866/67 the major powers advised the Ottoman Sultan to pass the authority over Crete to Greece to avoid any further bloody hostilities. The Ottoman government however refused but gave extensive autonomy and granted amnesty for the rebels. But the situation between the hostile members of the different religions didn't calm down especially because the Greek authorities permanently sent money, weapons and agitators to the island, ignoring the international agreement of 1869. Again In 1878 a major mutiny had to be put down by the legal Ottoman authorities under Mutkhtar Pasha, followed by more concessions to local self government in 1879 and again in 1889. This was good for the local people but of course not satisfying for the Greek government. They continued to stir the thorny situation by supporting the rebels with money and weapons. Again a critical point was reached when the Greek government started to transport armed soldiers of fortune to Crete in 1896 to support a new mutiny against the local government. In January 1897 the whole island was on fire, the majority (about 60%) of the inhabitants started to fight and kill the Muslim minority with the dedicated goal of joining Crete to the Greek Kingdom - a war between the Ottoman Empire and Greece was imminent. On the 15th of February 1897 2000 Greek soldiers, commanded by Colonel Vassos, landed at Crete to proclaim the union with Greece. In this situation the European major powers agreed to calm down the situation by blockading the island with ships to prohibit any troop transports, from whom ever, to Crete. Also an international peace force landed and took over control of several important places and ending any hostilities. Especially Russia, France and Italy were interested in weakening the Ottoman Empire and so they enforced their troublesome compromise to appoint the Greek Prince George as commissioner-ruler (Harmostes) of Crete but leave the island under the sovereignty of the Ottoman Sultan. The gendarmerie was newly formed under Italian control and the small local militia was put under control of foreign, mainly British, officers. No wonder that such a compromise against more than 30% of the inhabitants who were of Muslim religion and defacto deprived of their rights, could not work. After more mutinies, the largest in 1905, huge numbers of Cretan Muslims fled to the Ottoman mainland and at the end Crete became a part of the Greek Kingdom in 1913.


http://www.austro-hungarian-army.co.uk/troopscreta.htm

Had TCs not resisted by collaborating with Brits and Turkey, they would have shared the same fate of the Cretan Turks... So, before the cold war almost no TCs would have left in Cyprus... GR would have born in a Greek island and been a proud Hellene... :?
User avatar
insan
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 9044
Joined: Mon Jun 30, 2003 11:33 pm
Location: Somewhere in ur network. ;]

Postby Oracle » Sun Oct 17, 2010 10:02 pm

insan wrote:
Oracle wrote:
insan wrote:
wyoming cowboy wrote:sure it can but the tc and turkey are using the argument that it was an ethnic conflict which it wasnt, Cyprus has not used the cold war argument and keeps falling into the turk trap that a bizonal federation is needed to preserve the survival of the tc......if the cold war argument is used more effectively then the occupation of Cyprus becomes as antiquated as the Berlin Wall.


So, what about Cretan and Rhodesian Turks that had no chance to "create a problem" and most of them had to left the islands they inhabitted for 100s of years?

Why didn't the cold war affect the strategically important island Crete or Rhodes and cause a conflict there similar to Cyprus problem?


There are still many Turks in Rhodes. As for Crete, they left for Turkey. Nice decision!


The Land Forces on Crete 1897/98

Crete (Greek: Kriti, Turkish: Kirid, Italian: Candia) one of the largest islands in the Mediterranean Sea was in the last half of the 19th century an area of permanent troubles. The majority of inhabitants were of the Christian religion and rebelled against the Muslim minority which was supported by the local Ottoman government. After the great mutiny in 1866/67 the major powers advised the Ottoman Sultan to pass the authority over Crete to Greece to avoid any further bloody hostilities. The Ottoman government however refused but gave extensive autonomy and granted amnesty for the rebels. But the situation between the hostile members of the different religions didn't calm down especially because the Greek authorities permanently sent money, weapons and agitators to the island, ignoring the international agreement of 1869. Again In 1878 a major mutiny had to be put down by the legal Ottoman authorities under Mutkhtar Pasha, followed by more concessions to local self government in 1879 and again in 1889. This was good for the local people but of course not satisfying for the Greek government. They continued to stir the thorny situation by supporting the rebels with money and weapons. Again a critical point was reached when the Greek government started to transport armed soldiers of fortune to Crete in 1896 to support a new mutiny against the local government. In January 1897 the whole island was on fire, the majority (about 60%) of the inhabitants started to fight and kill the Muslim minority with the dedicated goal of joining Crete to the Greek Kingdom - a war between the Ottoman Empire and Greece was imminent. On the 15th of February 1897 2000 Greek soldiers, commanded by Colonel Vassos, landed at Crete to proclaim the union with Greece. In this situation the European major powers agreed to calm down the situation by blockading the island with ships to prohibit any troop transports, from whom ever, to Crete. Also an international peace force landed and took over control of several important places and ending any hostilities. Especially Russia, France and Italy were interested in weakening the Ottoman Empire and so they enforced their troublesome compromise to appoint the Greek Prince George as commissioner-ruler (Harmostes) of Crete but leave the island under the sovereignty of the Ottoman Sultan. The gendarmerie was newly formed under Italian control and the small local militia was put under control of foreign, mainly British, officers. No wonder that such a compromise against more than 30% of the inhabitants who were of Muslim religion and defacto deprived of their rights, could not work. After more mutinies, the largest in 1905, huge numbers of Cretan Muslims fled to the Ottoman mainland and at the end Crete became a part of the Greek Kingdom in 1913.


http://www.austro-hungarian-army.co.uk/troopscreta.htm

Had TCs not resisted by collaborating with Brits and Turkey, they would have shared the same fate of the Cretan Turks... So, before the cold war almost no TCs would have left in Cyprus... GR would have born in a Greek island and been a proud Hellene... :?


So now your fate on Cyprus is what? If you won't integrate, you don't belong here.

You are Turkish.

Go back to Turkey and leave us alone!
User avatar
Oracle
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 23507
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2008 11:13 am
Location: Anywhere but...

Postby insan » Sun Oct 17, 2010 10:20 pm

Oracle wrote:
insan wrote:
Oracle wrote:
insan wrote:
wyoming cowboy wrote:sure it can but the tc and turkey are using the argument that it was an ethnic conflict which it wasnt, Cyprus has not used the cold war argument and keeps falling into the turk trap that a bizonal federation is needed to preserve the survival of the tc......if the cold war argument is used more effectively then the occupation of Cyprus becomes as antiquated as the Berlin Wall.


So, what about Cretan and Rhodesian Turks that had no chance to "create a problem" and most of them had to left the islands they inhabitted for 100s of years?

Why didn't the cold war affect the strategically important island Crete or Rhodes and cause a conflict there similar to Cyprus problem?


There are still many Turks in Rhodes. As for Crete, they left for Turkey. Nice decision!


The Land Forces on Crete 1897/98

Crete (Greek: Kriti, Turkish: Kirid, Italian: Candia) one of the largest islands in the Mediterranean Sea was in the last half of the 19th century an area of permanent troubles. The majority of inhabitants were of the Christian religion and rebelled against the Muslim minority which was supported by the local Ottoman government. After the great mutiny in 1866/67 the major powers advised the Ottoman Sultan to pass the authority over Crete to Greece to avoid any further bloody hostilities. The Ottoman government however refused but gave extensive autonomy and granted amnesty for the rebels. But the situation between the hostile members of the different religions didn't calm down especially because the Greek authorities permanently sent money, weapons and agitators to the island, ignoring the international agreement of 1869. Again In 1878 a major mutiny had to be put down by the legal Ottoman authorities under Mutkhtar Pasha, followed by more concessions to local self government in 1879 and again in 1889. This was good for the local people but of course not satisfying for the Greek government. They continued to stir the thorny situation by supporting the rebels with money and weapons. Again a critical point was reached when the Greek government started to transport armed soldiers of fortune to Crete in 1896 to support a new mutiny against the local government. In January 1897 the whole island was on fire, the majority (about 60%) of the inhabitants started to fight and kill the Muslim minority with the dedicated goal of joining Crete to the Greek Kingdom - a war between the Ottoman Empire and Greece was imminent. On the 15th of February 1897 2000 Greek soldiers, commanded by Colonel Vassos, landed at Crete to proclaim the union with Greece. In this situation the European major powers agreed to calm down the situation by blockading the island with ships to prohibit any troop transports, from whom ever, to Crete. Also an international peace force landed and took over control of several important places and ending any hostilities. Especially Russia, France and Italy were interested in weakening the Ottoman Empire and so they enforced their troublesome compromise to appoint the Greek Prince George as commissioner-ruler (Harmostes) of Crete but leave the island under the sovereignty of the Ottoman Sultan. The gendarmerie was newly formed under Italian control and the small local militia was put under control of foreign, mainly British, officers. No wonder that such a compromise against more than 30% of the inhabitants who were of Muslim religion and defacto deprived of their rights, could not work. After more mutinies, the largest in 1905, huge numbers of Cretan Muslims fled to the Ottoman mainland and at the end Crete became a part of the Greek Kingdom in 1913.


http://www.austro-hungarian-army.co.uk/troopscreta.htm

Had TCs not resisted by collaborating with Brits and Turkey, they would have shared the same fate of the Cretan Turks... So, before the cold war almost no TCs would have left in Cyprus... GR would have born in a Greek island and been a proud Hellene... :?


So now your fate on Cyprus is what? If you won't integrate, you don't belong here.

You are Turkish.

Go back to Turkey and leave us alone!


Many nations integrated in Europe as seperate, independent states.. why not 2 nations of Cyprus island do the same? If you don't want to do the same go back to where you migrated from and leave us alone!
User avatar
insan
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 9044
Joined: Mon Jun 30, 2003 11:33 pm
Location: Somewhere in ur network. ;]

Postby Oracle » Sun Oct 17, 2010 10:30 pm

insan wrote:Many nations integrated in Europe as seperate, independent states.. why not 2 nations of Cyprus island do the same? If you don't want to do the same go back to where you migrated from and leave us alone!


Because, Cyprus has always been one state. You are just invaders who have been falsely given too much credence and our patience is wearing thin with you. You have never shown any desire to belong by integrating, so why do you now suddenly want to be responsible for a separate "state". You are worthless, failure, dependent liabilities who are free to form their own "state" in Turkey! :D
User avatar
Oracle
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 23507
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2008 11:13 am
Location: Anywhere but...

Postby insan » Sun Oct 17, 2010 10:38 pm

Oracle wrote:
insan wrote:Many nations integrated in Europe as seperate, independent states.. why not 2 nations of Cyprus island do the same? If you don't want to do the same go back to where you migrated from and leave us alone!


Because, Cyprus has always been one state. You are just invaders who have been falsely given too much credence and our patience is wearing thin with you. You have never shown any desire to belong by integrating, so why do you now suddenly want to be responsible for a separate "state". You are worthless, failure, dependent liabilities! :D


The 10 city-kingdoms of Cyprus established by people of various ethnic groups is a big lie then? :?
User avatar
insan
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 9044
Joined: Mon Jun 30, 2003 11:33 pm
Location: Somewhere in ur network. ;]

PreviousNext

Return to Cyprus Problem

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests