bill cobbett wrote:At the back of my mind... the victims in all this mess go far beyond those directly involved (and again best wishes to L and others in their disputes), the victims must also include the general CY Taxpayer (and there are some am sure).
How many millions of Euros (or could it be billions?) are owed by developers to the CY Treasury? Sums that ain't due 'til the title transfer process is started? How many schools and general hospitals or roads or health-care or even arms for defence etc etc would those ball-park amounts buy?
If am right goes to show the power of the developer lobby and the ineptitude and weakness of government in the face of it, when it doesn't act to make a small change to the law and, amongst benefits to house purchasers, collect taxes due.
Even more generally where does this fiasco leave the CY economy? Is it sitting on a time-bomb because of wider implications, given the sums that may be involved in this mess?
Developers taxes are anyones guess but the inland revenue is actually chasing a BUYER for the now bankrupt developers taxes, so maybe they have found a loophole.
For campaigners, the crux of the problem is that we have a system resulting from general inaction by successive governments; an absence of clamping down on conniving developers, lawyers and banks; bureaucracy and alleged corruption in public administration; a lack of confidence in the local legal process; and a body of property law that is not sufficient for preventing or penalising abuse.
The amnesty planned again this time, didn’t work five years ago, and it won’t work now.
Developers simply can’t afford to have Title Deeds issued because of their mortgages. I refer to the practice of allowing a developer to register a sales contract with the Land Registry instead of a Title Deed, the government has created a monster.
What really needs to happen is for a team of qualified legal experts to sit down, scrap the whole lot of the existing law, and rewrite it on a healthy basis. What is happening now is like giving an injection to a dead body which is already in the morgue.
It has been suggested by campaigners that one way of solving the deeds problem is for the government to focus on the estimated
€5 billion in transfer tax it would realise if and when the 100,000+ outstanding deeds are issued. This would create options for dealing with the developers’ estimated €4 billion debt.
The bottom line is that if the government gives a guarantee to everyone that they will get Title Deeds, this would solve the problem overnight, and help the economy.”
When loans go bad, the banks tend to chase the deed-less “owner” of a house standing on mortgaged land rather than the person who took actually out the mortgage.
Why would developers make payments on a mortgage when they know they will not be penalised if they don’t?