Tim Drayton wrote:Get Real! wrote:Tim Drayton wrote:Piratis, are you a racist?
By their very nature everyone is... and particularly those who deny it.
This is a valid argument.
I've strongly agreed with your every post here Tim, except this one.
This is not a valid argument, it is a fallacy. It is either a tautology or it is a distributive fallacy.
That someone is a racist is an empirical or historical matter (do they display racist behaviour or not ?) it is not a formal logical matter. The issue of denial is irrelevant, either way, to whether one expresses racist behaviour. In fact Get Real's issue of denial is manifestly illogical.
For example : Halil is the finest English poet in the world. Halil denies this accolade. According to Get Real's logic Halil's denial would be nothing more than a confirmation that he is indeed the finest English poet. A very silly argument.