Bananiot wrote:It is good practice to try and find contradictions in what an adversary says. However, trying to make inferences is an art mastered only by people without a biased mind.
I repeat what I said time and time again. It is to the interest of Cyprus that Turkey becomes full member of the EU. In fact, it will be great news for Greece too. Thus, if anyone infers from the above that I keep the interests of Turkey at heart, he better stay with the jokes section.
The Greek Cypriot people of Cyprus, as I said on many occasions, had the legitimate right to want enosis. The way the petition was organised did not even come close to a vote. Two books were used and if one felt he did not support enosis he had to open the red book, in front of everybody else, in order to sign against the national aspiration. I stress that in 1950 the GC's were legitimate in asking for enosis. However, their leaders betrayed them badly and turned enosis into a nightmare that eventually caused us dearly. Our leaders never considered the concerns of a large chunk of the population of Cyprus. In fact, they were so sure that the TC's would react that instead of consultation and giving of assurances to a population that could have listened, they schemed for the eradication of the TC's. The same leadership (made up of a pompous priest and a fascist general) chose the wrong form of struggle and started killing 18 year old English girls in order to achieve the sacred goal of enosis.
The legitimate dream of enosis was killed for ever by the leaders of the Greek Cyprus. These leaders are still worshipped today, by the natives, who have learned nothing from history and are ready to make similar and worse mistakes again.
One such mistake would be to deny that the TC's will be our equal partners in a reunited Cyprus.
My apologies for misunderstanding your earlier post. So we both agree that ENOSIS was a legitimate cause. Fine, let's move on.
What you are saying above is that Makarios and Grivas both made very grave errors of judgment. I accept this, and have been saying the same thing all along.
Makarios, in my view was an inadequate politician. He should not have signed the Zurich Agreements, and I say that because I disagree how the Zurich Agreement was ethnically based on 2 separate communities, and rights were afforded to those communities as opposed to the individual. I don't say this because I wanted ENOSIS, as independence is acceptable as far as I am concerned. Therefore, if the Zurich Agreement comprised a more conventional constitution, such as what is the case in many countries, where rights are afforded to Cypriot Nationals as equal citizens of the new Republic, then I would've been very happy.
Grivas, was no doubt a very strong and unyielding military mind, that never really abandoned ENOSIS. He too made very grave errors. For instance, his decision to start a National Struggle, in hindsight, has been proven wrong. If we waited a few years, Cypriots would have been able to successfully demand full self determination by 1960. Nevertheless, the struggle commenced, and Grivas had lots of nerve and courage to wage Guerrilla Warfare against the British Army. He, and his men, served their country admirably and under very difficult circumstances and against all odds. Many were killed fighting for ENOSIS/self determination.
My point is, despite both Makarios and Grivas making some grave errors in the 50s and again throughout the 60s, both were steadfast in their ideals and passion for Cyprus. Both men sincerely wanted the good of Cyprus. And even their relationship soured in the end, as Makarios was no doubt the realist and more stable, and Grivas being unable to forgo his objectives which he never abandoned.
Yes Bananiot. Both men are human. They made mistakes. But they are heroes! What they achieved between 1955-1959 was nothing short of remarkable. Their actions bordered insanity, for deciding to stand up against a superpower.
I don't have a problem with TCs being equal to every other Cypriot national. When this is skewed, we start to run into problems!