Tim Drayton wrote:cyprusgrump wrote:Tim Drayton wrote:Gasman wrote:[...]
Reminds me of when they had smoking and no smoking carriages on trains. And a non smoker would ignore all the empty non smoking carriages to get into the one with a smoker or smokers sat in it and immediately start complaining that it was a non smoking carriage!
[...]
And the reason that the smokers could not seek out a smoking compartment in the first place is?
Because it is a
smoking compartment Tim...
What would that tell you about the likely atmosphere in there...?
I have no idea what you are talking about. All I can say is that as a non-smoker all I wish for is the right not to have to inhale other people's toxic fumes in places that I have no choice but to be, such as public buildings, public transport or workplaces. I do not ask for a total smoking ban at such places, just for designated non-smoking areas to exist. I have an open mind about places like restaurants and bars that people can choose to frequent or not. I was perfectly happy when there were non-smoking compartments on trains, rather than having a blanket ban. However, I expect smokers to respect this. Quite frankly when I hear some ignorant, selfish inconsiderate oaf complain about being asked to refrain from smoking in a designated non-smoking compartment on a train where facilities for smokers are available, it makes me wonder why I should be so reasonable. Perhaps there has to be a rigid blanket ban if that is the only thing some people will understand.
I apologise, I miss-read your original quote... I thought you said
"And the reason that the non-smokers could not seek out a smoking compartment in the first place is?"
However, reference your last point...
I think it is unreasonable to tar (snigger) all smokers with the same brush because a small minority abuse the rules...
It is rather like saying that because a driver pulled out in front of you ALL drivers are bad.
I do completely agree with your point that there should be smoking and non-smoking areas so that we
all have the freedom to choose which we frequent.