lioness 2 wrote:Talisker wrote:cyprusgrump wrote:Talisker wrote:cyprusgrump wrote:Talisker wrote:
I am in no way excusing the dreadful actions of these individuals, but they themselves have grown up within the lowest levels of society, and it could be argued are the consequences (I daren't use the word 'victims') of the hugely unequal society that exists today. They probably have never been properly taught the difference between right or wrong, or good or evil, their minds were probably addled with drink or drugs, and the social expectations within this underclass (with which few of us have any real knowledge, familiarity or understanding) are entirely different to the rest of us.
I am not in favour of capital punishment. In our western societies we have the money and knowledge to improve opportunities and education, and improve the standard of living for the underclasses - we just choose not to do this, and use our prosperity in different ways (military spending, shoring up our financial insitutions, etc). They should serve their jail terms - I'm sure it will not be a pleasant experience for them. I don't believe they will be given new identities in another country. I hope efforts are made to educate and rehabilitate them, and make them aware of the evil nature of their actions, although I fear our prison service in the UK doesn't place this as a high priority.
Oh please!
Don't give me the old 'don't know the difference between right and wrong' argument!
Hang them.
I'm guessing you're a Daily Mail reader. I'd imagine you have no idea of social underclass, drug-fuelled societies, common practice of child abuse. To deny it exists is irresponsible in my view, perpetuates the problem, and therefore contributes to the next Baby P-like death. Will a few hangings cure societies ills, of which this one tragic death is but a single symptom? I think not.
This poor baby died as the result of prolonged abuse. Which was worse, the first time the baby was slammed against the wall, or kicked or whatever, or the one that finally killed? It has been acknowledged the social services system was at fault, the signs of abuse were there and the baby should have been taken into care. They were allowed to behave in this barbaric manner too long, hence the death. They progressed from being abusers to murderers. This could, and should, have been prevented.
I don't read the Daily Fail, no... you are confusing me with Z4.
You stated that these people didn't know right from wrong? Sorry, that is a fatuous argument. How could you survive life without knowing right from wrong...?
How would you managed not to burn yourself, start fights, steal things...? How could you manage to survive to adulthood without knowing?
They knew what they did was wrong - that's why they covered it up... didn't one of them hide when social workers visited? Why did he hide, did he think it was a 'game'? Hide and seek?
They concealed their evil acts because they knew it was wrong.
They are evil, they carried out unimaginable acts of cruelty against a defenceless child.
I'd hang them - I'd be happy to pull the lever. Perhaps others that 'don't know right from wrong' would consider their actions if they understood the consequences.
Most child abusers have themselves been abused when they were children. Therefore, the example they have been set, and experienced, is that child abuse is the norm. That cycle needs to be broken, and that requires much more sophisticated approaches than bringing back capital punishment.
Bullshit I have a friend who was abused as a child and she is the most caring loving mother you could ever wish for so that is just an excuse that some use and get away with using. As Cyprusgrump said it is a guaranteed method. Well said Cyprusgrump I take my hat off to you.
Thanks you!
The problem with Talisker's argument is that everybody that comes before a jury has an excuse for their actions. Should we dismantle the entire justice system and throw the doors of jails open?
Of course not. As you say, there are plenty of people that have the same background and experiences but choose not to steal/rape/abuse, etc.