kurupetos wrote:What is this rubbish re? You are for laughs...
bill cobbett wrote:Oracle wrote:bill cobbett wrote:Oracle wrote:bill cobbett wrote:Can I just put to bed this notion that North London Cypriot differs to any great extent from the CY spoken in CY and that it should therefore be regarded as a dialect of mainstream CY. Here in GB we have certainly acquired a number of words that are distinctive to our GB environment in the perfectly natural way that any Language of the People acquires new words. The fifty odd years or so since the birth of the London/GB CY community probably hasn't been long enough to develop a distinct dialect.
It is a distinct dialect as it is discernible as such. The fact it has many Anglicised words in the lexicon and more particularly, because the pronunciation is Angliphied, it can be considered as another dialect of Greek, with strongest similarity to most regional dialects in Cyprus.
Since the Academy's attempts to call it a language is based on writing it phonetically ... the pronunciation element is paramount!The phrases and sayings that we use here in London are identical to those used in CY CY (see the section on the Academy site above for a long list of phrases). So we have a situation where a 100% Urban Community (London CYs) uses sayings and phrases derived exclusively from the old CY village environment.
They can't be "identical" because there are many variations in Cyprus alone!
Agreed that London CY has acquired a small number of words from English.... In much the same way as Greek, German and even French(!) - we are not going to call French a Dialect of English are we now?
Nope, those are national languages, just as the national language of Cyprus is Greek. Your "London CY" is another dialect of Greek.
bill c. wrote:Cypriot as spoken/PRONOUNCED by Londoners and anyone else in the Diaspora, is an ACCENT.
No problem! Try developing a satisfactory phonological representation of the infinite variations of London CY as spoken by those in Wood Green compared to those in Finchley
Finchley Cypriot! Wood Green Cypriot! Croydon Cypriot! London Green Belt Cypriot! ( ) Still a matter (probably class-based; petit bourgeois versus proletariat) of ACCENT. ..................Gori!
..............................
Oracle wrote:bill cobbett wrote:Oracle wrote:bill cobbett wrote:Oracle wrote:bill cobbett wrote:Can I just put to bed this notion that North London Cypriot differs to any great extent from the CY spoken in CY and that it should therefore be regarded as a dialect of mainstream CY. Here in GB we have certainly acquired a number of words that are distinctive to our GB environment in the perfectly natural way that any Language of the People acquires new words. The fifty odd years or so since the birth of the London/GB CY community probably hasn't been long enough to develop a distinct dialect.
It is a distinct dialect as it is discernible as such. The fact it has many Anglicised words in the lexicon and more particularly, because the pronunciation is Angliphied, it can be considered as another dialect of Greek, with strongest similarity to most regional dialects in Cyprus.
Since the Academy's attempts to call it a language is based on writing it phonetically ... the pronunciation element is paramount!The phrases and sayings that we use here in London are identical to those used in CY CY (see the section on the Academy site above for a long list of phrases). So we have a situation where a 100% Urban Community (London CYs) uses sayings and phrases derived exclusively from the old CY village environment.
They can't be "identical" because there are many variations in Cyprus alone!
Agreed that London CY has acquired a small number of words from English.... In much the same way as Greek, German and even French(!) - we are not going to call French a Dialect of English are we now?
Nope, those are national languages, just as the national language of Cyprus is Greek. Your "London CY" is another dialect of Greek.
bill c. wrote:Cypriot as spoken/PRONOUNCED by Londoners and anyone else in the Diaspora, is an ACCENT.
No problem! Try developing a satisfactory phonological representation of the infinite variations of London CY as spoken by those in Wood Green compared to those in Finchley
Finchley Cypriot! Wood Green Cypriot! Croydon Cypriot! London Green Belt Cypriot! ( ) Still a matter (probably class-based; petit bourgeois versus proletariat) of ACCENT. ..................Gori!
..............................
Your accentuation or intonation although impact on your delivery, are still subject to your pronunciation. Your dialectic pronunciation is what phonological representation, with graphemes, can capture ... not your accent (might be nasal), but your pronunciation ("th" as in "this" or "dis", for example).
bill cobbett wrote:Oracle wrote:bill cobbett wrote:Oracle wrote:bill cobbett wrote:Oracle wrote:bill cobbett wrote:Can I just put to bed this notion that North London Cypriot differs to any great extent from the CY spoken in CY and that it should therefore be regarded as a dialect of mainstream CY. Here in GB we have certainly acquired a number of words that are distinctive to our GB environment in the perfectly natural way that any Language of the People acquires new words. The fifty odd years or so since the birth of the London/GB CY community probably hasn't been long enough to develop a distinct dialect.
It is a distinct dialect as it is discernible as such. The fact it has many Anglicised words in the lexicon and more particularly, because the pronunciation is Angliphied, it can be considered as another dialect of Greek, with strongest similarity to most regional dialects in Cyprus.
Since the Academy's attempts to call it a language is based on writing it phonetically ... the pronunciation element is paramount!The phrases and sayings that we use here in London are identical to those used in CY CY (see the section on the Academy site above for a long list of phrases). So we have a situation where a 100% Urban Community (London CYs) uses sayings and phrases derived exclusively from the old CY village environment.
They can't be "identical" because there are many variations in Cyprus alone!
Agreed that London CY has acquired a small number of words from English.... In much the same way as Greek, German and even French(!) - we are not going to call French a Dialect of English are we now?
Nope, those are national languages, just as the national language of Cyprus is Greek. Your "London CY" is another dialect of Greek.
bill c. wrote:Cypriot as spoken/PRONOUNCED by Londoners and anyone else in the Diaspora, is an ACCENT.
No problem! Try developing a satisfactory phonological representation of the infinite variations of London CY as spoken by those in Wood Green compared to those in Finchley
Finchley Cypriot! Wood Green Cypriot! Croydon Cypriot! London Green Belt Cypriot! ( ) Still a matter (probably class-based; petit bourgeois versus proletariat) of ACCENT. ..................Gori!
..............................
Your accentuation or intonation although impact on your delivery, are still subject to your pronunciation. Your dialectic pronunciation is what phonological representation, with graphemes, can capture ... not your accent (might be nasal), but your pronunciation ("th" as in "this" or "dis", for example).
A word is coming to mind ... Sounds like prodigy .... Erm .... Prosody ..... or is it .... Prodosy ..... must look it up.
Oracle wrote:The Cypriot wrote:A mother must love her child enough to know when to let it go. Unfortunately Greek mothers never do...
I love Cyprus. I will never let it go!
bill cobbett wrote:Question. Do those who "standardise" languages, those who seek to control languages also seek to control the culture and to manipulate society and the behaviour of the individual towards a preferred end?
bill cobbett wrote:What I find interesting are the relationships between language, culture, communities and even perhaps the individual. All interconnected.
Question. Do those who "standardise" languages, those who seek to control languages also seek to control the culture and to manipulate society and the behaviour of the individual towards a preferred end?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest