The Best Cyprus Community

Skip to content


Cyprus' Religious Cultural Heritage in Peril

How can we solve it? (keep it civilized)

Postby Oracle » Wed Jul 22, 2009 11:54 pm

Nikitas wrote:Re for GRs question, what can you find in a mosque, the answer is a lot, if you know where to look. Islamic art, excluding as it does any representation of persons, is very rich in decorative motifs tha can be found i removable tiles and paintings. Thankfullly no one has yet tried to trade in these from the RoC.


There is only one mosque of cultural significance (not of the Otto-Turks making) in Cyprus and that is very well looked after ..... so all the recent Turkish/TC mosques are insignificant as far as cultural heritage goes ...

Some of them would not have had "Planning Approval" in most European countries because of their ridiculousness ...
User avatar
Oracle
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 23507
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2008 11:13 am
Location: Anywhere but...

Postby shahmaran » Thu Jul 23, 2009 1:52 am

How full of shit you really are Oracle, I am suprized people can actually be around you regardless of the stench.
User avatar
shahmaran
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 5461
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 3:58 pm
Location: In conflict

Postby shahmaran » Thu Jul 23, 2009 1:56 am

Read again!!

Jerome Bowers, an associate history professor of the Northern Illinois University, claimed to the Washington Times that destruction of Turkish artefacts in Southern Cyprus was well-documented as well. “In Paphos, for example, the Camii Cedit was not only destroyed but replaced with a parking lot."
User avatar
shahmaran
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 5461
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 3:58 pm
Location: In conflict

Postby shahmaran » Thu Jul 23, 2009 1:59 am

Oracle wrote:
Nikitas wrote:Re for GRs question, what can you find in a mosque, the answer is a lot, if you know where to look. Islamic art, excluding as it does any representation of persons, is very rich in decorative motifs tha can be found i removable tiles and paintings. Thankfullly no one has yet tried to trade in these from the RoC.


There is only one mosque of cultural significance (not of the Otto-Turks making) in Cyprus and that is very well looked after ..... so all the recent Turkish/TC mosques are insignificant as far as cultural heritage goes ...

Some of them would not have had "Planning Approval" in most European countries because of their ridiculousness ...


If our mosques are insignificant than so are your Church, it is a 2 way street Oracle.

Luckily REAL European countries don't treat Mosques in such way...
User avatar
shahmaran
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 5461
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 3:58 pm
Location: In conflict

Postby Get Real! » Thu Jul 23, 2009 2:24 am

shahmaran wrote:Read again!!

Jerome Bowers, an associate history professor of the Northern Illinois University, claimed to the Washington Times that destruction of Turkish artefacts in Southern Cyprus was well-documented as well. “In Paphos, for example, the Camii Cedit was not only destroyed but replaced with a parking lot."

But where did you get this junk quote from that refers to a "Southern Cyprus"!

Oh honestly... :roll:
User avatar
Get Real!
Forum Addict
Forum Addict
 
Posts: 48333
Joined: Mon Feb 26, 2007 12:25 am
Location: Nicosia

Postby Oracle » Thu Jul 23, 2009 5:48 am

shahmaran wrote:
Oracle wrote:
Nikitas wrote:Re for GRs question, what can you find in a mosque, the answer is a lot, if you know where to look. Islamic art, excluding as it does any representation of persons, is very rich in decorative motifs tha can be found i removable tiles and paintings. Thankfullly no one has yet tried to trade in these from the RoC.


There is only one mosque of cultural significance (not of the Otto-Turks making) in Cyprus and that is very well looked after ..... so all the recent Turkish/TC mosques are insignificant as far as cultural heritage goes ...

Some of them would not have had "Planning Approval" in most European countries because of their ridiculousness ...


If our mosques are insignificant than so are your Church, it is a 2 way street Oracle.

Luckily REAL European countries don't treat Mosques in such way...


I never said your mosques are insignificant (although since you're all sooo secular, one could correctly assume such a thing) ... I said "the recent Turkish/TC mosques are insignificant as far as cultural heritage goes".

I'm afraid that is true shah ... you can't seize a country, erect some buildings and immediately say they are comparable to cultural heritage spanning thousands of years, which has become significant not just to the GCs you stole it from, but for millions of Christians and art historians all around the world!

You are just making enemies of many learned people with this clumsy attitude.

If you want to know how "REAL Europeans" (those unfortunate enough to have had experience of your "habits") treat some mosques ... then go to Spain! But then, they see how you have treated Ayia Sophia in Constantinople and many other ancient Churches ...
User avatar
Oracle
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 23507
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2008 11:13 am
Location: Anywhere but...

Postby Lit » Thu Jul 23, 2009 9:31 am

shahmaran wrote:
Oracle wrote:
Nikitas wrote:Re for GRs question, what can you find in a mosque, the answer is a lot, if you know where to look. Islamic art, excluding as it does any representation of persons, is very rich in decorative motifs tha can be found i removable tiles and paintings. Thankfullly no one has yet tried to trade in these from the RoC.


There is only one mosque of cultural significance (not of the Otto-Turks making) in Cyprus and that is very well looked after ..... so all the recent Turkish/TC mosques are insignificant as far as cultural heritage goes ...

Some of them would not have had "Planning Approval" in most European countries because of their ridiculousness ...


If our mosques are insignificant than so are your Church, it is a 2 way street Oracle.

Luckily REAL European countries don't treat Mosques in such way...


Here is some of the transcript from the actual briefing:

http://www.csce.gov/index.cfm?FuseActio ... N=90239950

In stark contrast to the situation in the North, which I recently had an opportunity to visit, scores of mosques and other Islamic places of worship are maintained by the Cypriot government in the southern part of the country.


...

The looting of Cyprus’ cultural heritage is not only a crime against Cyprus but a crime against humanity. We all are diminished by cultural loss of any kind. As a journalist based in the Eastern Mediterranean, I have seen a great deal of war, the scourge of the world’s cultural heritage. Indeed, we are just picking up the pieces of the wanton destruction of Europe’s
heritage during World War II. What has happened since Turkey occupied northern Cyprus 35 years ago has been even more dramatic than what took place in Europe.

The devastation is comprehensive and has taken place in a small area.
Churches, chapels, monasteries, libraries, museums and private collections of religious art and antiquities were looted. Religious and historical sites have been damaged, ravaged and destroyed. While the focus of this meeting is on the island’s religious heritage, this is rooted in 12,000 years of history which came before St. Paul and St. Barnabas brought Christianity to Cyprus.


...

The pillage was directed by Aydin Dikmen, a major Turkish black market dealer in Munich. He had developed close connections with Turkish Cypriot looters and smugglers well before 1974. The third phase began in 1980 and is ongoing. Today fewer than 500 Greek Cypriots, most of them elderly, remain in enclaves in the occupied North.


...

The direct responsibility of Turkey concerning the occupied area is clearly stated in the decision of the European Court of Human Rights in the Fourth Interstate Application of Cyprus against Turkey of May 10, 2001. Its decision – in its decision, the European Court of Human Rights stated inter alia that Turkey, quote “having effective overall control over northern Cyprus, its responsibility cannot be confined to the acts of its own soldiers or officials in northern Cyprus but must be also engaged by virtue of the acts of the local administration which survives by virtue of Turkey’s military and other support.

The movable property of almost every church was looted. Most of the mural or mosaic decorations were stripped away and a considerable number were located in international art markets abroad. Some well-known legal cases, as the Kanakaria case, Indianapolis court; the Antiphonitis case, Rotterdam court; the Dikmen case, Munich court, as well as the published study of Ms. Jansen demonstrate and prove the involvement and activity of Turkish looters in the occupied areas.

Furthermore, cases as the stripped away of 13th-century frescos of the Lysi chapel – now in Houston – and icons of the Koutzoventis monastery demonstrate in the most obvious way the cooperation and involvement of the Turkish armed forces in the illicit trade. Both the above-mentioned churches were situated in areas under the direct control of the Turkish military. And the icons and frescos were located later in the United States, Germany and in Holland.

There is no religious freedom in the Turkish-occupied areas of Cyprus for
non-Muslims since all of the communities I referred to earlier are either not free or severely restricted in their exercise of religious services, praying and maintaining the graves of their ancestors.



...

This is the reality of the situation in the Turkish-occupied area. In total contrast, the government of the Republic of Cyprus, through the Turkish Cypriot Properties Management Service and the Department of Antiquities repairs and maintains mosques and Muslim places of Worship in the government-controlled area, 17 of which, have been declared as “ancient monuments,” allowing the free exercise of their religious services.


...

Now, this particular situation must be compared to what
is going on in the government-controlled areas, where there is complete freedom
of religion for everyone. And I consulted someone who is connected with the
mosque in Nicosia and I said, what is the situation there?

He said there are three congregations in Cyprus in established mosques, which
have been restored and repaired, and there is a fourth congregation in Paphos.
The three established mosques are in Nicosia, Larnaca and Limassol. There is a
fourth congregation in a hall in Paphos. They haven’t yet managed to work out
some sort of arrangement for being placed in the mosque there. Anyway, they
meet every week. They have congregations of, sometimes, two or three thousand
on Muslim feast days in all three of these areas – in Limassol, Nicosia and
Larnaca.

And most of the people who are in the congregations are people who came to
Cyprus in the past decade, two decades. They are of Arab origin or Bangladeshi
origin or Pakistani origin. Apparently, Turkish Cypriots don’t attend the
mosques. So the mosques are maintained. The government of Cyprus provides a
salary for the imam and the congregations take up collections to pay the water
bill, the electricity bill and for small repairs. And that is the situation on
the two sides; it’s quite different. Thank you.


I think that everyone can go there and see it also for himself, what we’re seeing.


Right. In the RoC, you see a Mosque practically everywhere. And in the occupied north, you see desecration.
Lit
Regular Contributor
Regular Contributor
 
Posts: 2293
Joined: Tue Mar 24, 2009 6:32 am
Location: Right behind ya

Postby shahmaran » Thu Jul 23, 2009 10:59 am

Oracle wrote:
shahmaran wrote:
Oracle wrote:
Nikitas wrote:Re for GRs question, what can you find in a mosque, the answer is a lot, if you know where to look. Islamic art, excluding as it does any representation of persons, is very rich in decorative motifs tha can be found i removable tiles and paintings. Thankfullly no one has yet tried to trade in these from the RoC.


There is only one mosque of cultural significance (not of the Otto-Turks making) in Cyprus and that is very well looked after ..... so all the recent Turkish/TC mosques are insignificant as far as cultural heritage goes ...

Some of them would not have had "Planning Approval" in most European countries because of their ridiculousness ...


If our mosques are insignificant than so are your Church, it is a 2 way street Oracle.

Luckily REAL European countries don't treat Mosques in such way...


I never said your mosques are insignificant (although since you're all sooo secular, one could correctly assume such a thing) ... I said "the recent Turkish/TC mosques are insignificant as far as cultural heritage goes".

I'm afraid that is true shah ... you can't seize a country, erect some buildings and immediately say they are comparable to cultural heritage spanning thousands of years, which has become significant not just to the GCs you stole it from, but for millions of Christians and art historians all around the world!

You are just making enemies of many learned people with this clumsy attitude.

If you want to know how "REAL Europeans" (those unfortunate enough to have had experience of your "habits") treat some mosques ... then go to Spain! But then, they see how you have treated Ayia Sophia in Constantinople and many other ancient Churches ...


Whatever Oracle, you are not in the position to decide whether our heritage is considered significant or not, your excuse is worse than your baseless claims.

Secularism does not have anything to do with Mosques, it is a government issue, how is that related in any way?

Please elaborate your claims regarding the Spanish as I have no knowledge of the Ottomans ever reaching that far, maybe you are talking about the Arabs?

Probably all the same for you anyways :lol:

You want bias documents, well here you go Lit, it is worth hearing both sides as always;

The Greek Cypriot administration, which attempts to present itself as the
champion of conservation of cultural heritage, has, since 1963, been trying to
eradicate all traces of the Turkish-Muslim heritage of Cyprus. During the period
from 1963 to 1974, mosques, shrines and other holy sites in Turkish villages all
around the island were destroyed by the Greek Cypriots. Today the remaining
Ottoman Turkish shrines in South Cyprus have been targets of repeated arson
attacks. For instance, on 3 December 2000, there was an arson attack on the
Ömeriye Mosque, a significant Muslim shrine located in South Cyprus.
Furthermore, owing to the Greek Cypriot administration’s deliberate policy of total
neglect, the Turkish-Muslim heritage in South Cyprus is under threat of
disintegration. This utter disrespect for the Turkish-Islamic heritage has also been
confirmed by independent sources, including Mr. Ymenus van der Werff, General
Rapporteur of the Subcommittee on the Architectural and Artistic Heritage of the
Committee of Culture and Education of the Council of Europe, who reported the
following in his report published as a document of the Council of Europe on 2 July
1989 (AS/CULT/AA (41) (1), para. 5.3):
“We noted with regret the complete destruction of the main mosque in
Paphos. The whole area has since been flattened to give way for a widened
road junction and a car park. There is no memorial to the existence of the
mosque. Below the road a Turkish bath complex remains hidden in the rubble
and vegetation awaiting restoration. The Turkish Cypriot cemetery by the
nearby St. Sophia Mouttalos Mosque is dilapidated”.
User avatar
shahmaran
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 5461
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 3:58 pm
Location: In conflict

Postby Lit » Thu Jul 23, 2009 11:22 am

shahmaran wrote:
You want bias documents, well here you go Lit, it is worth hearing both sides as always;



You got some nuts on you. I reproduced an article from http://www.csce.gov/ which is an independent agency called "The Commission of security and cooperation in Europe" also known as the "U.S. Helsinki Commission". Why would it be biased towards the RoC? And we already know that whats in the transcript is 100 percent true as anyone who visits Cyprus can see it for themselves.
Lit
Regular Contributor
Regular Contributor
 
Posts: 2293
Joined: Tue Mar 24, 2009 6:32 am
Location: Right behind ya

Postby Oracle » Thu Jul 23, 2009 11:27 am

shahmaran wrote:
Oracle wrote:
shahmaran wrote:
Oracle wrote:
Nikitas wrote:Re for GRs question, what can you find in a mosque, the answer is a lot, if you know where to look. Islamic art, excluding as it does any representation of persons, is very rich in decorative motifs tha can be found i removable tiles and paintings. Thankfullly no one has yet tried to trade in these from the RoC.


There is only one mosque of cultural significance (not of the Otto-Turks making) in Cyprus and that is very well looked after ..... so all the recent Turkish/TC mosques are insignificant as far as cultural heritage goes ...

Some of them would not have had "Planning Approval" in most European countries because of their ridiculousness ...


If our mosques are insignificant than so are your Church, it is a 2 way street Oracle.

Luckily REAL European countries don't treat Mosques in such way...


I never said your mosques are insignificant (although since you're all sooo secular, one could correctly assume such a thing) ... I said "the recent Turkish/TC mosques are insignificant as far as cultural heritage goes".

I'm afraid that is true shah ... you can't seize a country, erect some buildings and immediately say they are comparable to cultural heritage spanning thousands of years, which has become significant not just to the GCs you stole it from, but for millions of Christians and art historians all around the world!

You are just making enemies of many learned people with this clumsy attitude.

If you want to know how "REAL Europeans" (those unfortunate enough to have had experience of your "habits") treat some mosques ... then go to Spain! But then, they see how you have treated Ayia Sophia in Constantinople and many other ancient Churches ...


Whatever Oracle, you are not in the position to decide whether our heritage is considered significant or not, your excuse is worse than your baseless claims.

Secularism does not have anything to do with Mosques, it is a government issue, how is that related in any way?

Please elaborate your claims regarding the Spanish as I have no knowledge of the Ottomans ever reaching that far, maybe you are talking about the Arabs?


I was referring to mosques in general since you reverted to accusations about us not behaving like "REAL Europeans"; so that was an example of how REAL Europeans can decide how to treat Mosques.

The oldest mosque in Cyprus is not Ottoman anyway, and a lot (most?) that are, were once Churches ... So go figure about the significance of your borrowed heritage!

The new mosques are not less significant culturally just because you think I say so ... but by virtue of how cultural significance is itself measured by historians. You can't rush "ownership" and label things as culturally significant when their being stolen from other countries/cultures was so recent. That is the job of historians, these things are catalogued and they will weigh forever on your "culture". You stand to be forced to give them back.
User avatar
Oracle
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 23507
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2008 11:13 am
Location: Anywhere but...

PreviousNext

Return to Cyprus Problem

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests