Ombudswoman report reveals racist cover-up
By Anna Hassapi
OMBUDSWOMAN Iliana Nicoalou has slammed an attempt on the part of Ministry of Education officials to cover-up a racist attack against a 14-year-old Cypriot student of African origin.
In her report, Nicolaou notes that although the Minister of Education Andreas Demetriou reacted in a correct way to the incident, characterising it as racist, Ministry officials disobeyed instructions, presenting the attack as an incident of school violence and not of racist behaviour.
“There was a reluctance to recognise a problem that does exist, to simplify its analysis and evaluation, and an ease in ignoring, unfortunately, incidents of this nature,” the report noted.
Nicolaou expressed satisfaction with Demetriou’s handling of the matter as the Minister speedily visited the 14-year-old at hospital and then visited Akaki high-school, where the attack against the pupil took place.
The Ombudswoman, however, criticised the handling of other Ministry officials who tried to play down the racist character of the incident, branding the case as an example of ‘anti-social behaviour’ on the part of some pupils.
“This is not an isolated incident and we call authorities to abandon inactivity, indecisiveness, silence and confusion which result in the reproduction of such incidents,” the report stated.
“The relevant authorities are silent on the real parameters of the incident. We get an image of an education system that is obviously confused and refuses to accept the nature of this racist incident,” the report continued.
The Ombudswoman’s report refers to the attack against Margaritas Doukou, a Cypriot citizen from Sudan which took place on 18 December 2008 at a school sports day. On that day, teams from Akaki high-school, which Doukou attends, and Stavrou high-school played against each other. When the game ended and Akaki high-school won, one pupil from Stavrou high-school pushed a pupil from Akaki and when Doukou intervened to defend her friend all hell broke loose.
A group of pupils started hitting the 14-year-old while chanting racist slogans such as ‘Blacks get out of Cyprus’, ‘Go clean up my grandfather’ and ‘Take €10 and come with me’.
The 14-year-old managed to escape and locked herself in a classroom. While she was there, a female student stood outside the door and shouted ‘Daughter of the Black, I will not rest unless I kill you’. The 14-year-old was taken to hospital where it was confirmed that she had been hit on the head and stomach, sustained a concussion, headache and stomach ache.
In her report, Nicolaou also noted the reluctance of police officers to file a formal report on the case. Doukou’s father told police that he wanted to file an official report, but police officers reportedly tried to discourage him and repeatedly asked the 14-year-old if she preferred that the students who attacked her get a warning from police. Doukou insisted on filing the case, and police submitted the file following the intervention of the Ombudswoman’s office.
The teachers association of Stavrou high-school punished the pupils who were involved in the attack against the 14-year-old, but did so not on account of them being racist, but because they swore at the deputy headmistress of the school.
On January 13, 2009, the teachers expelled the female pupil who reportedly hit the 14-year-old, giving the following reasons to justify their decision: active involvement in the incident, swearing at the deputy headmistress on the day, as well as on the following days. Five more students were suspended for a few days for their involvement in the events.
Copyright © Cyprus Mail 2009