zan wrote:Kikapu wrote:zan wrote:You could say that the TCs are the heros in all of this...Look at how much opposition we had...Thank heavens for Dr. Kucuk and Denktas!!!
Kikapu
WHAT ! Your posts just confirms that it was a mistake for the TC's to withdraw from the RoC and not return back as Inönu
BEGGED them to do so, which gave Makarios a free hand to do what he wanted, no matter how much of a HERO you see Küçük and Denktash in making that decision.! What more can I say, Zan.?
"Timing these Greek-Cypriot tactics is interesting. Makarios apparently fully understands that (1) Turk-Cypriots could strengthen their case and weaken his by participation, (2) that such participation was not likely while security forces were primarily GOC and British, and (3) that formal establishment UNFICYP is strategic moment for Kutchuk to insist on participation. He appears to have made moves re Denktash and acting minister appointments to goad Turks into frittering away energies in protests and legal arguments until opportunity has passed. Makarios' tactics will probably succeed if Turk-Cypriots continue to sit on hands and feel sorry for themselves.
If Kutchuk would return to his office because of UN presence, he could be serious embarrassment to Makarios. Even if Makarios could insist successfully that all measures of GOC taken during Kutchuk's absence are legal and not subject to Vice-President's veto, he would have difficulty not forwarding future bills or measures to Kutchuk as required by constitution. His only effective alternatives would appear to be: (1) to maintain that Kutchuk was rebel who tried to set up separate Turk-Cypriot administration and therefore had lost authority in government (difficult argument to sustain if GOC has, as it claims, been sending invitations to Kutchuk and other Turk-Cypriot officials to attend scheduled meetings) or (2) to maneuver Turk-Cypriots into holding back from participation until too late.
He appears to be operating under second alternative. With each passing day that his tactics perpetuate Turk-Cypriots boycott of government, he increases general acceptance GOC as presently constituted, strengthens his contention that Turk-Cypriots are insurgents and weakens ability UN to remain neutral between two communities.
In this connection, British Embassy informs us GOT has asked HMG to intercede with Makarios and protest to UNSYG on behalf Denktash. HMG has informed GOT British forces Cyprus part of UNFICYP and they cannot make independent intercessions with GOC. (FYI. UKUN, however, has been instructed to call Denktash problem to attention SYG on humanitarian grounds. End FYI.) Turk Embassy informed Dept of GOT concern re Denktash but made no request for USUN action and Dept plans none."
Zan wrote:When you finish reading your little American war story comics in which everything is done right...In hindsight, then perhaps you can start to read some adult literature that tell of wars as they are....Nothing is for sure and mistakes are made...Especially with the Americans causing more deaths to their own than the enemy...
I don't know what you are talking about, Zan.!
Zan wrote:Makarios put every opstacle in the way and when they did finally try to return they were met by armed guards and a GC person in their place...
I did not read this in anything that you have provided. Did you forget it by any chance.! The nearest thing to the above is what you gave us
"This took form of maintaining that until such time as there was political settlement satisfactory to Greeks or at least until Turkish community here recognized fact that GOC was undisputed government, there was no possibility of Turkish Ministers or even Turkish civil servants returning to work. Mrs. Soulioti said that she did not go this far, but that unless there was freedom of access for Greeks who have legitimate business in present Turkish-controlled areas. (i.e., area north of Nicosia and Kyrenia Road), she saw no reason why Turks should be allowed come back to work in government in Greek area. (This strong attitude reflects position taken by Makarios in farewell conversation with Ambassador Wilkins and me reported in Embtel 1060.)/3/"Zan wrote:The constitution was never changed only on paper...It is not adhered to otherwise the "RoC" could not function..Now come back and tell me "What else could they do"...You have always been a defender of the politically wrong Greeks...I would expect no more....
Then stop repeating the same misinformation that the constitution was altered.
As I gave you an football analogy few weeks ago. If some members of the team refuses to play and walks off the pitch middle of the game, the team plays on with the rest of the players. The GC's chose to continue to play, and we the TC's, became spectators from the sideline. We are now once again wanting to be part of the team, so lets see what will be the terms of the rules this time around.!
Inönu must have understood the situation on the ground no matter what the difficulties for the TC's ministers might have been, but he also knew damn well, that the TC's needed to get back ito the RoC government and they did not. Don't you think Turkey could have used it's guarantor powers to make sure that the TC ministers were allow to continue being part of the government if in fact they were being pushed around by Makarios, but when the TC's refused to go back, there was nothing Turkey could have done. Obviously, there were bigger and better things in the minds of the TC ministers that would require Turkey's help later on and did not need her help top get back in the RoC government.
Zan wrote:You don't even answer the whole post...Just one little line of my own comment and think you have done the job......
You gave us plenty, Zan....thank you.!
Inönu was right to be concerned by the TC's ministers refusal to go back to the RoC government, and because of those mistakes, they haunt the TC's in their isolated "trnc" today.!