Kikapu wrote:Kifeas wrote:Paphitis, I have a complete disrespect for the Turkish media and publications, as they are nothing more than factories of fabrications and distortions for the sole aim of blinding and disorienting the Turkish people. When it comes to Cyprus, 99% of the cases they are out of this planet when it comes to their analyses and claims on facts. I have a strong feeling the case of Alex. Downer is one of those rare 1% cases in which they do not lie. I learned so well in which cases they lie or distort for propaganda purposes, and in which they do not, to the extent that I can recognise immediately as soon as I read something if they do the one or the other. The few doubts I had when I first read those reports in Hurriyet, yesterday morning, vanished as soon as I watched Downer's supposedly "rejection" comments on TV last night. He was not convincing at all, that he did not say those things.
Downer will play an important role, when things come to a dead-lock and he will be required to submit a report to the UN SG and the UN SC in which to administer blame for the impasse. After what he said, I no longer trust he will do his job with the outmost integrity that is required for his role! He will try to safeguard Turkey's interests and throw the blame on both sides equally, even though it is clear that the Turkish side comes to the negotiating table with profoundly extreme, unreasonable and illegitimate demands. He has already -fortunately for us and unfortunately for him, revealed the colours of his shield.
Kifeas,
I believe the whole news from Hurriyet is crap regarding what Downer has said in private meetings with Turkish Officials and here are my reasons.
First of all, in the West and in open societies, it is easy to leak information out from inside the government by unauthorized individuals, and at times, the government does the same by leaking information deliberately, but in close societies and "deep states", leaks are almost unheard of by unauthorised individuals because the penalty will be very swift for them, so the only way any information from the Turkish Government could have come out to the press, would be a deliberate leak by the government, and if Downer did say what was claimed by Hurriyet, then Downer will know that the Turkish Government leaked out the information deliberately which he will not be very happy about it since Downer will know who were in the in the room with him. I believe Downer did not say those things and the Turkish Government deliberately leaked a false report to the press for purely for propaganda purpose to try and get Christofias to agree on any settlement that is demanded by Talat as well as for the GC's to accept it. So I think the Turkish Government have their own
"Deep Throat" on the leak given to Hurriyet, but this one is well known to the Government, because in this case,
"Deep Throat" was the Turkish government itself. There is no way in the world, that the Turkish Government would release such sensitive matters to the press and get Downer pissed off if in fact Downer did say those things.
What would the Turkish Government gain by exposing Downer to the press and the world.? It will cause Downers dismissal from the settlements talks.! Does Turkey want Downer of the talks.? I don't know. What do you think.?
You may be on to something very significant here Kikapu, although it is extremely difficult to prove.
I can tell you that many in the Greek Community are out for his neck. The same also applies with the Turkish Community. Both groups are very traditionally Labour, and hence believe that Alexander is the wrong man for the job purely based on Partisan Politics.
The Turkish Community does not like him because Alexander Downer is setting up a business called Bespoke Approach, in partnership with former
Labour Senator Nick Bolkus who is of Greek Heritage. The Greek Community is upset because they are paranoid that Alexander Downer has appointed a Turkish Academic on his advisory panel, which I can confirm is not the case. If only people knew the real facts.
They are also upset because of Australia's very "special" relationship with the US, and they fear that ultimately Alexander Downer will serve US interests which are pro Turkish. I have not been able to find any evidence of this, yet. Unfortunately, Kifeas line of thought is very common here in Australia amongst the Greeks, and also the Turks.
What I am increasingly suspicious about is exactly what you are eluding to. That Turkey is trying somehow to undermine him because of Alexander Downers opposition to establishing
"Time Frames" which he believes will be detrimental to the peace process, and will result in a another failed plan. This does not suit Turkish Interests or her EU ambitions.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Downer
Another thing people seem to forget, is the fact that Alexander Downer was instrumental and responsible for the liberation and freedom of
East Timor. It is these credentials which are probably the reason why he was chosen as UN envoy on Cyprus.
http://www.abc.net.au/7.30/stories/s52206.htm