The Best Cyprus Community

Skip to content


The Cyprus Problem for Dummies .....

How can we solve it? (keep it civilized)

Postby Viewpoint » Mon Jan 25, 2010 1:27 am

Malapapa wrote:
Viewpoint wrote:Its not a ruling against the TRNC, our countrys name is not quoted on any documents, you yourself claim it doesnt exsist,


It's illegitimacy is peppered all over the English High Court judgement.

Lord Justice Pill:
In July 1974, the army of the Turkish Republic invaded the north of the island and set up an administration for that part of the island its forces occupied. The Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (“TRNC”) was declared in 1983. It has not been recognised by any state apart from Turkey.


Viewpoint wrote: if you persist with this childish approach then you leave me no option but to brand you a pezevenk someone who whores his wife out for money.


:lol: What a desperado you are.


Keep it clean or keep hitting below the belt the choice is yours.
User avatar
Viewpoint
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 25214
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 2:48 pm
Location: Nicosia/Lefkosa

Postby BirKibrisli » Mon Jan 25, 2010 1:50 am

Kifeas wrote:
BirKibrisli wrote: You say the new conditions for the next "marriage" will be chosen by the people themselves...Yet,you want to force the TCs to drop Turkey's guarantees and adopt your full democracy principles...Why? Is it only a GC prerogative to refuse to accept terms of an agreement (even after signing them!)? will you be equally forgiving of the TCs if and when they say they did not agree to such and such but had no choice but sign at the time??? What's good for the goose????


Bir, there is no GC hand that has the nerve to sign an agreement that will bestow unilateral intervention rights to Turkey, in the form of guarantees as we came to know them from the 1960 agreements between Greece, Turkey and the UK. There are reasons for that, and I am sure you know them all, but let me repeat them here once more.

1. Turkey is not a stable democracy, with a healthy political culture and system. It cannot guarantee its own peoples’ human, social and political rights. Turkey needs other countries to guarantee its own peoples’ human, cultural and political rights (see what happens with the Kurds and other minorities,) and it is very provocatively rich from her part, and that of the TCs, to demand that such a country should have unilateral interventions rights into another country, an EU member as a matter of fact, with a much healthier political culture than her own. That the RoC, as it stands today, has a much healthier political culture, I am not the one saying so but all international ratings in all relevant aspects and areas of concern.

2. Turkey had used once these hypothetical intervention rights, and it failed miserably to protect the human rights, constitutional order and sovereignty of Cyprus. Its intervention, in the form of invasion and occupation, evidently created a situation much worse than the one it supposedly came to rectify, and we all experience these results as of this day.

3. Cyprus is a sovereign country, just like Turkey, and a member of the UN and the EU as of 2004. If one sovereign country claims to retain the right to unilaterally intervene into another sovereign state, without this being valid in retrospect, then the principle of sovereign equality between UN members, as it is safeguarded by the UN Charter (article 2, par.1,) is nullified. Such a notion, i.e. that one sovereign country has the right to essentially invade another one at will -as long as there is some pre-text, outside any UN SC mandate, goes against the most fundamental principle based on which the UN was founded. Furthermore, Cyprus being a member of the EU, such a notion goes against the principles based on which the EU exists; more so when it extends to a country that is not even an EU member state itself.

If the Turkish side insists on this anachronistic and essentially illegal under international law provision, then I am afraid there will be no solution. Now, if there will be no solution, all sides stand to lose, including the GC one. However, I happen to believe that the TC side and Turkey are the sides that stand to lose the more, in the long run. Occupation and retention of northern Cyprus by Turkey will indeed become the biggest “white Elephant” example in the modern history, even after the last TC will vanish from the annals of history. I frankly suggest that if indeed the TCs and Turkey are interested in a solution, they should try and find other ways to address the issue of security of the TCs, from the hands of the bloodthirsty GCs -i.e. from the hands of those that many of them seek medical treatment on a daily basis. There are many ways to address this area of concern for the TCs, such as in the form of a mixed local and international force that will include Greece and Turkey, but in which no one country alone will have the right to take unilateral action. We are open to all proposals, BUT one which will allow Turkey to think or believe it has the legitimacy to repeat what it did in 1974 and afterwards.

And since you used the mariage example, no one in his right senses accepts to enter into a marriage relationship, in which the mother-in-law or the father-in-law will have the keys of the bedroom and the right to permanetly station themselves there, when the couble goes in bed every night. If you are ready to accept such a marriage, then so be it, but we are not. It goes against our dignity.


well,dear Kifeas,we have our own Catch 22...Turkey will not leave the picture until a compehensive solution is agreed to,put into operation,and found to work...And GCs will not agree to a comprehensive solution till Turkey is out of the picture...What are we going to do???Start talking about Partition???keep the status quo till the balance of power changes and the North is liberated by war? Wait to reclaim the GC properties in the North one by one in courts??? What??? :( :( :(
User avatar
BirKibrisli
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 6162
Joined: Tue Aug 16, 2005 4:28 pm
Location: Australia

Postby Get Real! » Mon Jan 25, 2010 2:02 am

BirKibrisli wrote:What are we going to do???Start talking about Partition???

Talk about partition? :? Why would you need to talk about it with the RoC... just go right ahead what's keeping you? :lol:
User avatar
Get Real!
Forum Addict
Forum Addict
 
Posts: 48333
Joined: Mon Feb 26, 2007 12:25 am
Location: Nicosia

Postby YFred » Mon Jan 25, 2010 2:06 am

Get Real! wrote:
BirKibrisli wrote:What are we going to do???Start talking about Partition???

Talk about partition? :? Why would you need to talk about it with the RoC... just go right ahead what's keeping you? :lol:

Mavro laoman buten bu irtes? What's your name Zulfikar Ali Butto.
User avatar
YFred
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 12100
Joined: Mon Jan 05, 2009 1:22 am
Location: Lurucina-Upon-Thames

Postby Get Real! » Mon Jan 25, 2010 2:06 am

BirKibrisli wrote:Turkey will not leave the picture until (1) a compehensive solution is agreed to, (2) put into operation, (3) and found to work...

In other words like NEVER! (willingly) :wink:

Do you know what I like about you? You expose the TC & Turkish scandals so well that there can’t possibly be any naïve fools left around the world reading this forum! :)
User avatar
Get Real!
Forum Addict
Forum Addict
 
Posts: 48333
Joined: Mon Feb 26, 2007 12:25 am
Location: Nicosia

Postby BirKibrisli » Mon Jan 25, 2010 2:28 am

Kikapu wrote:

BirKibrisli wrote:1...do you believe the core of the Cyprus problem was a desire by Turkey to expand her territories????

2...Do you think the TC climb into the enclaves in 1963 was simply to open the way for Turkish occupation??? They had no legitimate fears for their lives????

3...Would you consider the TC move into enclaves as "ethnic cleansing"?
Or does that only apply to the GC expulsion from the North???

Let us get your honest opinion on these points...You do not of course have to answer these questions....You can simply say it is none of my business...But ,please, don't side step them again and pretend to answer...


1. The last 36 years says "YES". Had they came and did what they were suppose to do and left, then the answer would be a "NO". While I was in Turkey last October, some Turks believed that Turkey should have taken all of Cyprus back in 1974. If it wasn't for expansion purposes, then there would not have been any need to expel GCs from the north if we were to overlook at her all other faulty. If the TCs were their major concerns to help them from the GCs, Turkey should have come in 1963 and to spared us the bad times from 1963-1974. I do not want to hear any excuses why Turkey did not come in 1963 because America did not let her, because then Turkey should have never become a Guarantor Power to Cyprus and particularly for the TCs, if she needed permission like a child needing a permission from her teacher to go to the bathroom. Turkey is part responsible for the sufferings of the TCs along with those seeking Enosis and Taksim. I'm sure that's not what you wanted to hear, but that's what happened.

2. Yes, the TCs did fear for their lives and it was also a very ideal way to try and bring most TCs together for that eventuality for Taksim by their leaders. Naturally Turkey would have loved to take part of Cyprus once the British left. After all, they had it for 300 years at one point, so what better way to take it back, if not in full, but in part by coming in to save the TCs from the GCs. Many variables played part once the 1960 constitution was signed. From then on, the race was on as to who was going to achieve Enosis or Taksim first, or for much better outcome, by having a double Enosis-Taksim with as little blood shed as possible. It appears that the extremist from the Enosis felt they deserved 100% and was their aim, but in 1968, Makarios had already given up on the whole idea for Enosis, but Taksim kept on going.

3. YES, it was ethnic cleansing, speaking from experience that we went through in Küçük Kaymakli. We were uprooted at the point of a gun, shipped to imprisonment, and then dropped off someplace in Nicosia which was not where our home was. I don't know the exact stories on how all the other TCs ended up in enclaves, but I'm sure they had somewhat similar experience, if not at the point of the gun from the GCs, but at the point of a gun from the TMT.!


I think you got the meaning of my first question wrong,Kikapu...I was asking for your opinion of the "core" reason for the Cyprus problem...You gave me an analysis of your take on the events since 1974....I don't think you believe at the core of Cyprus conflict is Turkey's territorial ambitions...You might want to clarify your positon on that issue,or you might not..

This illustrates the dangers of ignoring a large part of our recent history,and beginning one's analysis from 1974....This is what most reactionary GC nationalists do on this forum..It does not suit them to think of all those bloody events which preceeded 1974...Anyway...I think we have probably exhausted ourselves and our arguments,for now.I still have no idea why you simply refuse to openly citicise our GC compatriots' role in the overall conflict..You will remain a puzzle...I cannot argue with your demands for full democracy and true federation etc,but I can tell you are being unrealistic,and simply reinforcing the rectionary GC nationalist beliefs,which in my opinion is the biggest obstacle to finding a solution...As dear Pyro keeps reminding us,this is only an on line forum,and even if we agreed to any solution here,including your own BBF proposals,nothing will change in reality...My belief is firm...As long as nothing is being done to address the emotional stress and trauma of both sides,Cypriots will remain deeply divided by mutual resentment,bitterness and distrust...This is not an ideal situation for talking about coming back together in any sort of arrangement...You have chosen your path on this forum,and I have chosen mine...I will not give any comfort to the reactionary GC nationalists here by putting the boot into my own people any more...I stand by everything I said in the past...I am the same person,just somewhat wised up by the overall treatment of my community on this forum...I will confront those reactionaries here whenever I see them,and I will use he same weapons they do,and return all the compliments in kind....It will not help foster understanding or trust,but hell,it will make me feel a lot better... :wink: :lol:
User avatar
BirKibrisli
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 6162
Joined: Tue Aug 16, 2005 4:28 pm
Location: Australia

Postby BirKibrisli » Mon Jan 25, 2010 2:44 am

YFred wrote:
BirKibrisli wrote:
YFred wrote:
Viewpoint wrote:
YFred wrote:
Viewpoint wrote:
paliometoxo wrote:your not originally tc vp? or you where living in england for a long time beofore or duirng the war?


My parents are both TC I was born and raised in the UK now living in the beautiful TRNC.

I hope you realise how lucky you are.


I know YFred, I returned in time to raise my children here in the TRNC among our people, the standards in the UK have gone down hill.

It does depend on where you live. There are still very good pockets even in London. But I do envy you and intend to return after I retire. I am going to plant a vineyard in Lurucina to introduce the world to Lurucina Zivania.


I think I found my occupation post retirement... :lol:
YFred,will you let me help you making all that zivania if I return to Cyprus....???You can pay me in kind,all the zivania I can drink.... :lol:
Deal????

You are welcome to stay there for free as long as you want, However although I have the land as yet not planted the vines or dug foundation for the villa and the swimming pool in the middle surrounded by the almond trees and figs. Now that is heaven and it has a beautiful view of the valley.
Its about 15 minutes drive away from Nicosia too I might add. :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:


Add a wallnut and a carob tree,Yfred,and you got me for life...
Perhaps you can let me build a mudbrick house in one corner,to remind me of my beloved Istinco...We can dig a well too,and I can go and fetch my drinking water from it,as I used to go and fetch it from the running spring water as a child...On warm summer nights I can sleep on the roof watching the bright night sky and drinking myself to oblivion with zivania...I can think of worse ways to live your autumn years,mate,what? :wink: :lol:
User avatar
BirKibrisli
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 6162
Joined: Tue Aug 16, 2005 4:28 pm
Location: Australia

Postby BirKibrisli » Mon Jan 25, 2010 2:51 am

Get Real! wrote:
BirKibrisli wrote:Turkey will not leave the picture until (1) a compehensive solution is agreed to, (2) put into operation, (3) and found to work...

In other words like NEVER! (willingly) :wink:

Do you know what I like about you? You expose the TC & Turkish scandals so well that there can’t possibly be any naïve fools left around the world reading this forum! :)


And you know what I like about you,GR? You expose the reactionary GC nationalist mindset so well that all the naive fools around the world are trampling each other to read and write on this forum... :wink: :lol:
User avatar
BirKibrisli
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 6162
Joined: Tue Aug 16, 2005 4:28 pm
Location: Australia

Postby Expatkiwi » Mon Jan 25, 2010 5:10 am

BirKibrisli wrote:
Get Real! wrote:
BirKibrisli wrote:Turkey will not leave the picture until (1) a compehensive solution is agreed to, (2) put into operation, (3) and found to work...

In other words like NEVER! (willingly) :wink:

Do you know what I like about you? You expose the TC & Turkish scandals so well that there can’t possibly be any naïve fools left around the world reading this forum! :)


And you know what I like about you,GR? You expose the reactionary GC nationalist mindset so well that all the naive fools around the world are trampling each other to read and write on this forum... :wink: :lol:


I don't really care for GR, either, but he has repeatedly said that he doesn't like Greek interference either. Think what you like about him, but he is a RoCy person first.
User avatar
Expatkiwi
Regular Contributor
Regular Contributor
 
Posts: 1454
Joined: Fri Jun 17, 2005 11:24 pm
Location: Texas, USA

Postby denizaksulu » Mon Jan 25, 2010 9:54 am

YFred wrote:
BirKibrisli wrote:
YFred wrote:
Viewpoint wrote:
YFred wrote:
Viewpoint wrote:
paliometoxo wrote:your not originally tc vp? or you where living in england for a long time beofore or duirng the war?


My parents are both TC I was born and raised in the UK now living in the beautiful TRNC.

I hope you realise how lucky you are.


I know YFred, I returned in time to raise my children here in the TRNC among our people, the standards in the UK have gone down hill.

It does depend on where you live. There are still very good pockets even in London. But I do envy you and intend to return after I retire. I am going to plant a vineyard in Lurucina to introduce the world to Lurucina Zivania.


I think I found my occupation post retirement... :lol:
YFred,will you let me help you making all that zivania if I return to Cyprus....???You can pay me in kind,all the zivania I can drink.... :lol:
Deal????

You are welcome to stay there for free as long as you want, However although I have the land as yet not planted the vines or dug foundation for the villa and the swimming pool in the middle surrounded by the almond trees and figs. Now that is heaven and it has a beautiful view of the valley.
Its about 15 minutes drive away from Nicosia too I might add. :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:



...not to mention that your villa will be well guarded by the massed armed personnel carriers and tanks of the Cypriot National Guard. :lol: :lol:
User avatar
denizaksulu
Forum Addict
Forum Addict
 
Posts: 36077
Joined: Thu May 10, 2007 11:04 am

PreviousNext

Return to Cyprus Problem

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests