Oracle wrote:tessintrnc wrote:I like the short stories - especially the ones for Children, The selfish Giant, and the Happy prince can still move me to tears. The plays - I like some, but not all, and I heartily dislike some of his poetry!! But all in all - a great Irish writer (crap husband though)!!!!
I was in fact lucky enough to have been bought a collection of his entire works, and unlucky enough to have it turn to mush when the workshop was flooded out
His Children's stories are not much liked by children from what I have experienced/heard. So you haven't actually read any of his works.I found "The Picture of Dorian Gray" dull and witless and attempted a few of this other novels but finished no others. He was good at the one liners but that does not make a "World's greatest writer". A biography I read on him went some way to make him an interesting character though.
As a playwright he wasn't a touch on Noel Coward.
On the other hand Roald Dahl is amazing for both adults and children and I have read all his short stories and most of the Children's books. All were incredible adventures and real page turners.
tessintrnc wrote:Oracle wrote:tessintrnc wrote:I like the short stories - especially the ones for Children, The selfish Giant, and the Happy prince can still move me to tears. The plays - I like some, but not all, and I heartily dislike some of his poetry!! But all in all - a great Irish writer (crap husband though)!!!!
I was in fact lucky enough to have been bought a collection of his entire works, and unlucky enough to have it turn to mush when the workshop was flooded out
His Children's stories are not much liked by children from what I have experienced/heard. So you haven't actually read any of his works.I found "The Picture of Dorian Gray" dull and witless and attempted a few of this other novels but finished no others. He was good at the one liners but that does not make a "World's greatest writer". A biography I read on him went some way to make him an interesting character though.
As a playwright he wasn't a touch on Noel Coward.
On the other hand Roald Dahl is amazing for both adults and children and I have read all his short stories and most of the Children's books. All were incredible adventures and real page turners.
what?? I studied Wilde at school and through the years have read MOST of his works. Dorian Gray - I agree - rather average but each to their own - hence my preference for his short stories and the plays!! Have YOU actually read any of his works apart from his one and only novel?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests