garbitsch wrote:Today's slavic people of Macedonians live in the territories of old Macedonian empire. Alexander the Great was Macedonian-Greek. But later the people living in that territory either became Slavised or the Slavic people settled down. Now in the Territory that is called Macedonia was living the Slavic people who call themselves Macedonian because of the territory they live in. It's like the Egyptians. Although their culture, language and religion have nothing to do with ancient Egyptians, nobody bars them the use of the terms "Egypt" and "Egyptian". The Hellenic Republic must compromise with Macedonians on these terms, that there is a Macedonian Republic with Macedonians speaking Macedonian. But these people are not the descendants of the Greek Macedonians who spread Hellenism to the Middle East etc. You cannot expect a people to change their own nationality and call themselves something else. This is same by forcing Greeks to call themselves something else, e.g. Athenians. I hope you guys got my point.
You described the situation quite accurately, although i do not agree with you point that those people are actually Macedonians. They are Slavs who happened to live in the lands of the ancient Macedonia. Other than that, there is absolutely no attribute to their way of life, religion, culture and tradition that can link them with ancient Macedonia. If they are Macedonians then what are the real Macedonians who live in Greece, like myself for example? We are one group of people and they are another. It would be best if they distinguished themselves from us, simply because we want our tradition to be...well, ours! Names, symbols and everything that comes with it are very important elements of preserving the local tradition of Macedonia.
Apart from 'emotional' reasons, the story has important geopolitical implications. The Skopjans had, and most likely still have, territorial ambitions towards Northern Greece, which given the chance, they would love to materialize. The name is just a start.
Yet this is a rather far fetched scenario because their economic life depends largely on Greece. In 1994, if i am not mistaken, they put the Sun of Vergina, an ancient Macedonian, symbol on their flag, claiming that everything that this symbol stands for is their. The then Greek government embargoed them and they changed their minds within weeks.
They have a big mouth simply because they are backed by Uncle Sam, Turkey and other minor players in the region.