denizaksulu wrote:Kikapu wrote:Talat's version of UNIFICATION.!!!??? He wants everything what he wants, but no mention of what the GC's want. Even on the property issues, he only offers what suits him and nobody else. Unless he climbs down his ivory tower of arrogance and starts negotiating on finding peace, he will soon be kicked out of office and replaced with a Denktash type, which will bury any hopes for the TC's to improve their lives, because the status quo will remain, and the EU dreams of the TC's and Turkey will be just a mirage, and the likelihood of future wars will become a reality. So Mr Talat, start using your head and not your Red Lines to find peace, or else it will be those same Red Lines that will be prevent your people to move forward into the EU, the West and for a better future.
Hi Kikapu.
Pt of Interview relating to the properties of refugees:
EuroNews: "How about the property issue? because this is another important topic."
Mehmet Ali Talat: "Property issue will be solved in terms of either
compensations, or exchange or restitution. There are three options. And an agreement will have provisions regarding this issue."
First I am not happy about the way the interview was conducted. Talats answers were not 'confidence inspiring', except for the properties issue.
Do you see any other alternative to his three 'offers'?
What other
realistic alternatives are there, considering most of the land on the Northern coast has been sadly concreted over?
I once asked GR this while looking at the concrete jungle below us. I do not recall his answer, if any.
Hi Deniz,
Talat used the words
compensations, or exchange or restitution but not
right of return.Restitution can mean that if one wants to stretch the word, but it can also mean compensation. It's not unusual for politician to use different words meaning the same thing.
The property issue is one of the contentious issues in this settlement. If we are going to have a True Federation and not a Confederation under BBF, then every Cypriot will be free to return to their home villages if they choose to. They will also have the right to claim their land and properties back when ever possible, which means, that any public works projects such as roads, schools, hospitals government building and so on built on any GC land, can only be compensated with today's market value. The RoC government would need to compensate the TC's for the loss of their land in the south, at today's market price also.
I made this provision on my peace plan last year, and that was, any TC family occupying a GC home in the north should not be forced out of the place they have been living for the last 30+ years, but they should be given the first option to buy the place from it's original owners, at today's market price. If the TC's family can pay for it , or trade land in the south if they have some, or sell their land in the south and pay the GC owner of the house from that money. Perhaps a time frame can be set up, say 12 months or so, for the TC family to get their finances together to complete the deal with the GC owner. The TC family and the GC owner can arrange what ever deal they want between themselves. If it's apparent from the beginning that the TC family is not going to be able to come up with the money, then they will need to vacate the place within 12 months.
But of course, there may be a GC house as well as GC land (over 1 donum) all in the same place, because of this "exchange" program. Any land other than the one donum that the GC house sits on, that land can be returned back to the GC's immediately no matter what the TC family paid for it. It will be no concern of the GC owner who pays the TC family for that land. There is a good chance, that the GC land was given to the TC family in the "exchange", so they have not paid any money that they will lose. But lets take my cousin's husband's case. He bought lots of GC land at £20 per donum, but claims they are worth £3,000 per donum now. All of that land must be returned back to their original GC owners at no cost, and if any money needs to be paid to the husband, it can only be £20 per donum plus interest or nothing at all. He knew that he was buying GC land, hence the fact that it was
DIRT cheap.
As for those who came to Cyprus from abroad to get rich on GC land in the north, should seek compensation from the person who sold them the GC land, and all the land and property should be returned to the GC owners within 12 months if its a dwelling, and immediately, if it's just a bare land, unless they too want to make a deal with the GC owners. This talk by Talat that GC land has changed too many hands and it is difficult to return the land is a bunch of crap. Even if it changed hands 10 times, they all knew the risks they were taking, so whats going to happen more than likely, just like in the game of
"musical chairs" where the last one who is standing without a chair to sit on, because there is one chair less than people going around in a circle, and if I may put it delicately, will be
"shit out of luck". The tenth and the last person who bought the property can go and sue the person who sold him a GC property and so they go all the way down the
"totem pole" until it reaches the steps of the former "TRNC". The GC owner does not get involved in this at all. It will not be his problem. All the same rules will apply to TC land and property occupied by GC families in the south.
So Deniz, my bottom line is, if it's a dwelling where people are living in them, then they should be given the first option to buy the property at today price so to limit the number of people that will need to look for other places to live. This may not be what the GC may want, but some degree of compromise will need to be made to show good will and understanding. In the end, the TC's and GC's will make better neighbours than forcing people to move at any cost. My guess is, most will not be able to afford the price of today's cost, therefore they will move out. On the other hand, I do not expect too many GC's wanting to move to the north, so they will just simply take ownership of their properties, and rent them out to the TC families, to those who were not able to buy it in the first place. Same deal with commercial buildings and hotels.