by CopperLine » Fri Apr 25, 2008 6:02 pm
Pantheman,
Let's suppose that you are right and Turkey 'has to learn'. Then the question is what is the best (i.e, most effective) and fastest way of learning : one way is to do so by offering and honouring EU membership. This gives both a carrot and a stick. Those fundamentalists who reject out of hand Turkey's EU membership can offer neither carrot nor stick.
A bit of EU history is instructive for this example. The application of Greece, Spain and Portugal were all encouraged by existing EEC members in order to encourage and consolidate the democratic transformation of those states following (long) periods of military dictatorship. Each of those three states were not adequately democratic etc when they applied for membership but the prospect of membership acted as the carrot for reform. I think that this model is applicable to Turkey. (Again, if Turkey does not democratise, make constitutional changes, revise the criminal code, etc, then who is going to suffer ? Turkish citizens, and Cypriot citizens. So again, you can have Turkey pissing in or you can try to stop Turkey pissing at all).
Following Boomers and Oracles 'logic' Turkey is irremediable; their argument is basically one of saying if Turkey reforms and joins the EU it will still fuck the EU and Cyprus and anywhere else ('cos that's what Turks are like'); if it doesn't reform and join the EU it will still fuck the EU and Cyprus. Not only is that a literally hopeless argument, but is is of absolutely no help to Cyprus.[/i]