QAMERSLAND wrote:Tim Drayton wrote:QAMERSLAND wrote:Niki wrote:This is meaningless - if a Muslim woman admitted she had been raped or even worse reported a rape she would be an outcast within the Muslim community. You cannot deny this.
A Saudi gang rape victim was recently sentenced to 200 lashes and 6 months in prison as she was seen in a car with a man that was not related. She was only released after the media outcry. How sick is that? You think this is fair?
she was punished to go against the law and because she went against the law, she was raped.
the punishment was to warn other women to follow the law. same as you punish to a murderer to be the lesson for others to stop doing it otherwise all will start to kill each other.
and once gain i saw all famous news channels were try hard day and night to show this news to malign Islam.
every country has right to make law according to their need and desire.
who are you to criticize the law of Saudi Arabia?
did they come to tell you to ask why do you reticules (man made) laws in your countries?
Even worse, I hear from good sources that the prisons in Saudi Arabia are full of women from South Asian countries like the Phillipines and Indonesia who were working as maids and were raped by their employers, made pregnant and then, since they are unmarried, imprisoned for committing adultery. Of course, the rapists go unpunished. Sharia law - no thanks!
there is death penalty for rapist in Islam. and my advise is to you is not to believe whatever you hear. check the news before passing on to others
Correct, so why is this penalty not applied in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf states to their own nationals for instances of murder and rape when the victim is from South Asia?
I lived in Qatar for two years and I know from personal experience that there exists a system of racism in that part of the world that makes the system of Apartheid that was once practiced in South Africa look like political correctness.
There are plenty of reliable reports on the Internet describing the conditions endured by foreign domestic workers in Saudi Arabia. Here is one such report:
http://www.cdhr.info/Articles/Trafficki ... GulfStates
It is common knowledge in Qatar that housemaids from countries like India/Sri Lanka/Indonesia/the Phillipines frequently endure serial rape over the course of their employment, especially by their employers' adolescent sons. Of course there are good people and good employers there as well. But, it is very prevalent. The dirt-poor country of Nepal, which sends many workers to the Gulf and whose economy relies on the money they send back to their families, nevertheless refuses to let its women travel to the Gulf because of the fate that would await them. I say that this is very much to Nepal's credit.
So, if Sharia law punishes rape by death, why do rapists go unpunished in Arabia and, instead, their victims suffer punishment? Either Sharia law stinks, or the Gulf countries are not applying it properly. If the latter is true, then surely people like you should, rather than trying to push Islam down Westerners' throats, devote their efforts to making the inhabitants of the Arabian desert, who claim to be such pious Muslims, live according to the rules to which they claim to subscribe.
Here are a few more little nuggets from the Gulf.
I heard from somebody who worked for the ambulance service in Doha, Qatar, that one day they were summoned to a certain roundabout to collect some workers who had been injured on a building site. They were puzzled because there were no building sites in that vicinity. They nevertheless proceeded to this location and could see no injured pople. Suddenly, a lorry turned up. There were piles of injured people stacked up on the back of the lorry like carcasses. The lorry stopped, the drivers (Gulf Arabs of course) then proceeded to toss the people piled up on the back down onto the ground as if they were sacks of potatoes and drive off at speed. The injured people were Pakistanis and apparently some of them had serious injuries. Yet, the drivers of the lorry saw fit to throw them onto the ground as though they were inanimate objects. This is how they treat their fellow Muslims! Apparently, the contractor responsible for the building site did not want the authorities to know where the accident had occured and was happy to resort to such a subterfuge to keep its location secret.
Another time, the same person was sent to collect a corpse from a labour camp housing South Asians. Just to put you in the picture - and I know, because I have visited such places - South Asians are housed in camps consisting of prefabricated huts each of which is divided into two rooms and filled with four bunk beds so as to accomodate eight people. Nomally there is air conditioning, but apparently the camp in question did not even have this facility. When the crew turned up to collect the corpse, it emerged that it had been left for many days in a bunk bed in a room shared by eight workers without even air conditioning, and this in the summer in Qatar when the temperature exceeds 50 degrees. In other words, the employer could see nothing wrong with making them live for days at close quarters with a moulding corpse in the scorching summer heat of the Arabian desert.
I have heard from people who have lived in Kuwait that here young people run down and kill South Asians who are crossing the road as a kind of passtime. I myself was once crossing the road at one of the major intersections in Doha, Qatar on a pedestrian crossing with the green man showing. I was suddenly pulled back by an Indian national who was walking behind me. I turned and saw that a young Qatari national was driving towards me at full speed in his Toyata land cruiser. Perhaps Qataris were beginning to discover this "sport". The evil, perverted grin across that young man's face is etched into my memory.
I also worked in Libya, and once got into a conversation with a Palestinian colleage there about my experiences in the Gulf. He told me - and he is a pious Muslim who prays five times a day, by the way - that in Kuwait young women who are nationals of that state entice young non-Gulf Arabs such as Palestinians and Syrians to ride out into the desert where they have sex, and then the women immediately kills this man so that he can never speak about this incident. This they are able to do with impunity
Of course, Sharia law in theory has punishments for all of these transgressions. However, practice has obviously become seriously decoupled from theory.
Why will those same people who are happy to burn flags and destroy embassies when a few cartoons appear in an obscure Danish newspaper not raise their voices to condemn the serious transgressions of basic human rights that take place on a dialy basis in the Arabian Peninsula, a place that is supposed to be so holy?