observer wrote:KifeasI know thousands of international media reports around the 1974 events, which all talk about a Turkish invasion of Cyprus, and I know none talking about a Greek "invasion!" Yet, many pathetic brainwashed Turks talk about a Greek "invasion" and a Turkish "intervention!"
It is clearly an Invasion from outside. in flagrant violation of the Independence and sovereignty of the Republic of Cyprus. The so called coup was the work of the Greek officers staffing and commanding National Guard.
Makarios speech to the UN Security Council 19 Jul 1974
The Athens Court of Appeal, in its decision of March 21, 1979, also held that the "intervention of Turkey in Cyprus was legal: ".... The Turkish military intervention in Cyprus which was carried out in accordance with the Zurich and London Agreements was legal. Turkey, as one of the Guarantor powers, had the right to fulfil her obligations. The real culprits... are the Greek officers who engineered and staged a coup and prepared the conditions for this intervention.")
Decision no: 2658/79 Dated 23/3/79
So, we are being brainwashed by the Turk-loving propagandists Makarios and the Athens Court of Appeal are we?
I think that the propogandist boot is on the other foot, the GC propaganda machine trying to re-write history.
Sorry DT for applying the wrong name to the item I originally quoted. Simple human error.
1.) My little propaganda machine observer, there is no such decision by any Greek court, and even if there was one, it is not (never) up to national courts to decide on the legality or illegality of international events and /or disputes! This is the job of the UN and international courts! Learn a bit about international law, before farting here!
2.) The RoC has in numerous occasions invited Turkey to accept a hearing and a ruling by the Hague International Court of Justice (ICJ) on the legality or illegality of the Turkish invasion! Turkey has consistently refused to accept such a procedure (it unfortunately requires the mutual consent of both parties in the dispute for such a trial to take place.) Why, if Turkey (and you of course) are so sure about the legality of the invasion, do not accept a trial by an international court?
3.) It is irrelevant the way in which Makarios had once choosen, at that particular time, to described the Greek Junta and GC National Guard coup against his government; presumably in order to win sympathy and mobilise the international community more effectively, to the actual fact that it wasn’t an invasion by Greece as such, but an illegal intervention! Invasion occurs only when a country uses its military strength in order to forcefully violently break in and land troops into the territory of another country, in order to occupy parts or the whole of it, exactly like Turkey did in 1974! The coup was carried out by the RoC National Guard under the command of mainland Greek officers already seconded into its hierarchy, which were already stationed in Cyprus and paid by the RoC! It did not seek to occupy any specific territory of Cyprus, as such, but only overthrow and replace the elected government. No Greek troops came from outside at that particular time, either peacefully or violently, in order to take part in the coup. Such an act is regarded a coup, and to the extent that for this coup there were orders from outside, then we have an illegal foreign intervention by Greece, a foreign country.
Invasion is something else. Invasion is what Turkey did after the coup, on the 20th of July 1974!
What Greece did was an illegal intervention that caused the death of just about 100 people. The list of casualties is out there for everyone to read it! What Turkey did was an illegal invasion that eventually caused the death of as many as 6,000 people (including all the missing ones and including also some 500-600 TCs.) What is even worst, even though the coup lasted for only 6 days and then it collapsed, the illegal Turkish invasion went further by ethnically cleansing the entire GC indigenous population of 37% of Cyprus, and permanently occupied illegally the northern 37% of Cyprus for the last 33 years!
4.) The Turkish invasion (as well as the Greek intervention via a coup) were both illegal under the UN Charter. The UN Charter specifically states that no military intervention or invasion into the territory of any UN member country can take place by any one other country, without the specific approval of the UN Security Council. The UN charter also says (article 103) that any other international agreement or treaty (such as the 1960 Zurich and London agreements) that are in conflict with the provisions of the Charter, the UN Charter rules over and takes priority as the highest of all treaties! The UN Charter is accepted and ratified by all nation-states, once they become members of the UN, and this of course includes Greece, Turkey and the UK!
The Turkish invasion was
illegal, because it
violated the
UN Charter, by default the highest international treaty on earth!