Filitsa wrote:Hello Zan,
The gentlemen's club is a social club whereas religion is a societal institution. On their faces, both may discriminate, but before you condemn one or the other, their purposes/intents and the damage they do to the good of society should be considered. Discrimination is not always bad. I teach my children to choose their friends with discrimination, meaning to choose friends who will make them better people as opposed to choosing friends who will make them degenerates.One says that women have a certain role in society and the other that they are not equal in ability so what is the difference but words.
The former may be true, but the latter merely celebrates the differences between men and women, just as the Garden Club and Ladies' Club do.
zan wrote:I think the same things in the UK were called Gentlemens clubs and the fight to allow all women into say Golf clubs is going on even today so I would think twice about condemning one culture above another because of religion.
OK ZanFilitsa wrote:Hello Zan,
The former may be true, but the latter merely celebrates the differences between men and women, just as the Garden Club and Ladies' Club do.
Eliko wrote:The Q'uran is therefore an absolute truth, one LETTER of alteration is not permitted and it is because of those facts that all the misunderstandings occur.
Eliko wrote:Given that they accept the teachings of their Q'uran and practice them accordingly, I can see no reason why WE, (of other beliefs), should not afford them the same rights as we ourselves enjoy.
Southerner wrote:zan wrote:I think the same things in the UK were called Gentlemens clubs and the fight to allow all women into say Golf clubs is going on even today so I would think twice about condemning one culture above another because of religion.
This must be one of the most inept comparisons to date.
Firstly Islam is a religeon not a culture.
Women are not forced to become none particpating members of a gentlemens clubs and golf clubs only to be executed if the give up their membership.
In Pakistan right now an attempt is being put through parliament to make it punishable by death for converting from or leaving Islam. Some culture, some religeon.
Strangely enough I've never heard of an honour killing by an asian father against his son, it only seems to happen to daughters. Some culture, some religeon, so manly.
Cowards beat women (to quote the prophet, the weaker sex)not real men. Some culture, some religeon, so manly.
zan wrote: Can you point me to the part in the Koran that says that people should be killed if they convert or perhaps the Pakistanis are making it up as they go along. If you have read other posts of mine then you will know that I have no time for religion of any sort but to get yourself in a tiff because someone does something in the name of a religion is just madness. Was it not Bush that said that god was on his side in the fight against Saddam. He is now seen as the biggest terrorist around so is we to condemn Christianity because of that. The use of culture and religion are not a million miles from each other. The bible it self was written to bring all the cultures and the traditions together in one book and one religion or do you really believe that it was written with the hand of god.
I will use one example of how culture and religion is linked together in many ways. Take your Christmas tree for example. The tree it self was always outside the house and considered bad luck if brought into the house. The decorations on the tree are traditionally red because the original decorations were the intestines of the sacrificed animals to the gods so that they had plenty of lambs in the spring.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests