The Best Cyprus Community

Skip to content


Occupied north: A human rights black hole

How can we solve it? (keep it civilized)

Postby zan » Mon Apr 23, 2007 12:59 am

humanist wrote:Murataga I do not have any problem with you guys having independence, that is rtotally fine if that is what you want, but just remember that you cannot have independence on the violation of the rights of other cypriots. Go ask Turkey for portion of her territory and build your own country on land that is given to you, not taken from others without their consent and then you have independence. The more that I am non this forum the more I conclude that Turkish Speaking Cypriot leadership and people have no intention of unification and this is clear by your post, Murataga. Well that once again is fine but you cannot expecta that you can build a country on stolen land and not have consequences of international economic embargo.

The same old same old, yes in the 60's some Turkish speaking Cypriots expreienced discrimination and violence, however confiscating half the country and building a so called republic, is wrong also, and if we learn from Israel there cannot be a country build on stolen land and not have ramifications. Is that the future you want for all Cypriots? It has been stated many times before that Turkish speaking Cypriots DO NOT give a hoot about Greek Speaking Cypriots, but that aside is that the future you want for future Turkish Speaking Cypriot children, always living under the fact that their country is build on stolen land? Two wrongs cannot make a right, my friend. However I am not here to convince you that unification is better than separation.



I am sorry that I have been away for a while and left guys like Murataga and VP alone to face these wolves like Humanist :wink: but my health has taken a turn for the worse and until I can regain control I am afraid that I will not be posting as often as I like.

Humanist
You have slowly but surely found the party line that Piratis and others like him like to quote over and over again. The fact that you keep using the term "human rights" does not excuse the lack of human rights that the GCs have exhibited for the TCs for so long. Since entry into the EU, you guys seem to be bandying this term around as if you have treated us fairly all along. You also said that you are now convinced that we do not want unification but....OH! How soon they forget. Although the Annan plan was not to your satisfaction, you seem to forget that the TCs voted an emphatic yes to unification. Instead of turning your anger on the RoC for not negotiating properly and using that positive move by the EU to unify our island, you now try to blame us for it. All this bullshit about the TC on the street knowing all about the details and therefore that is why they voted yes is just that, Bullshit. It is quite clear that your beloved TPap is more interested in supreme power for the GCs than he is for unification. You too have become a staunch "pass the buck" poster that seems to bend and distort the recent past. The TCs have realised that they will no longer be Cypriots in a united Cyprus but will be downgraded to a community status only and this is simply not acceptable. This whole thing has become more and more a fight against the GCs wanting total union with Greece. We seem to be the new fighters against the EOKA type warfare that so far has been political and now you have repeated what others have said (in threatening terms) that if we do not bow down to this we will be attacked. Where are the human rights in that. So your name as "Humanist" really means "Greek Humanist". You are really only fighting for your corner and your refugees and your rights and not for everyone’s equal rights.

The party line seems to be that the negotiations are over. The RoC is in the EU and that is the standard that we need to reach so we might as well give up. You guys have reached the point that Cyprus has to be at and we are 100% wrong. History seems to be repeating it self and all the fears that we had then and have been restating here is to be ignored. I think you (as a whole) are being a little bit naive in thinking that that is the end of the story. You are also being very inconsistent in your sympathy for the way we have been treated and the remedy for our fears and for us to vote for unification once again. What you guys fail to understand time and time again is that if you have it so good over there and we can have the same, why oh why is there no mass immigration to the south. Is it because we like to be with our own and you guys have pushed us away so far that we do not feel like the Cypriots you want us to be. Free Cyprus is so right when he says that there are no Cypriots left on the island. Only Greeks and Turks. I guess in those terms there is only one thing left to do and that is to fight our corner while you fight yours. This can only mean that we will be more dependant on Turkey and will therefore feel more Turkish than Cypriot. The GC refugee problem will just be a regrettable consequence of the whole problem and no matter how much you shout about it, it will just be another consequence. We cannot sit around waiting for you guys to start thinking in terms of our well being so we will go forward as best we can. WE HAVE NO OTHER OPTION. Without concessions from you in that respect you have taken away all other options from the table.
User avatar
zan
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 16213
Joined: Wed Nov 02, 2005 8:55 pm

Postby Viewpoint » Mon Apr 23, 2007 1:21 am

humanist
VP north Cyrus is not yours it is mostly stolen land from Greek Speaking Cypriots who have been ousted and threatened with death if they return to their properties, loud clear and very simple for even the most idiotic person to comprehend.


Ask yourself the following questions, Why were you ousted? did you contribute to the current situation? and do you have anything to do with a non solution?

Who is threatened with death if they return to the north?, GCs cross every day and no harm comes to them, some even reside here. I agree that GCs should be allowed to live in the north with us under the TC administration just like GCs recommend we do by moving south.

We also CHOOSE not to live with each other. If I can have a Turkish family living two doors up, from mine acknowledge, respect and interact with them in Australia, if I can shop at the local Turkish Pide shop on fortnightly basis and interact with the owners laugh and even attempt to learn Turkis I am sure it can be achieved in Cyprus.


You CHOOSE to live there under foreign rule, we live under our own rule that is the difference even the simpliest mind can work that out. The problem is how do we strike a balance to ensure th epast does not repeat itself and that both communities are fairly represented in power sharing.

You are right there is NO magic solution< however there can be a human solution, nothing on this planet has been built without the desire to do so. If we stoped our little human minds for a moment, left our victim identity behind, left our hate and prejudice to one side we can achieve a solution to the Cyprus Problem. This is all about power struggles and ego and the positive benefits to some people who have gained and stand to gain much more from a divided Cyprus. I have said it before and I make no apology about it and will say it again, I believe that you and yur family are one of those who stand to gain much more.


Total rubbish I have said it before and will say it again your are wrong in your assumptions.

I would welcome any move by your leadership that invited greek speakers to reclaim their properties in the north.


Property commission in the north? 130 cases now lodged.

I would doubly respect any turkish speaker who approaches the RoC governement requesting financial assistance to re-buld and reclaim their properties in the south and at that point invites the greek speaker owner of the property they are currently occupying to return. And it brings joy to my heart even tantalising this idea that a turkish speaking facly would say we have our own land in paphos lets claim it, lets invite the refugee of this home infornt of TV and media and give them their key back. That would be the start of a solution VP that would be a start to a new Cyprus, No politicians, but everyday people doing the best for a new United Cyprus. Even if one family did this you will see that when they returned to their home in paphos they would be given a heroes welcome and their deed will be appreciated and heralded by many on both sides of the divide. Does such family exist? Better still would your divisive regime and order from Turkey allow for this to happen, all it would take is one family on either side of the divide and here is your magic solution.


This has already occured, TC ladies house was renovated and handed back, what has it changed? TCs still do not want to live in the south under GC rule just as GCs do not want to go south why do you find this so hard to comprehend?
User avatar
Viewpoint
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 25214
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 2:48 pm
Location: Nicosia/Lefkosa

Postby humanist » Mon Apr 23, 2007 1:37 am

WOOOF! WOOF! :)

Sorry to hear about your illness Zan. I too have been away from the forum for a fortnight now just returned the other day, only to find that we are no closer to bringing our people together than we were 33 years ago.

Once again, Zan. I acknowledge that in the lead up to the late 60's Turkish Speaking Cypriots had experienced discrimination and violence in the hands of some (not all) greek speaking Cypriots. For that I personally apologise. Perhaps this apology and acknowledgement needs to come from the President of Cyprus. There is no doubt that the actions of some greek speaking Cypriots in the past imopacted on the relationship between the two communities. So now we have acknowledgement of the unfairness and ill treatment of turkish speaking cyps in the 60's a violation of their human rights to feel physically safe and have equal political, social and economic power can we move on? As far as enosis was concenred what a "malakia" (waners notion) that was. The fact that it did not succeed tells your that most greek speaking cyp's did not want union with Greece and I for one thank God for it not happenning.

About the human rights bandying since EU membership, that is tottaly incorrect, Greek speaking Cypriot have all along been arguing for human rights and an end of the violation of such rights since 1974. The only difference is that is now been asked for in a different arena, heard by no one, cared by none.

I am not being inconsistent with my empathy as I give you or anyone else sympathy as sympathy is a paternalistic idea that I wish not to engage, in.

Since I have come on the forum I have maintained several core beliefs for myself and what I wish for the Island of Cyprus. These are, Unification, demilitarisation of the Island, rights of all Cypriots to return to their properties, register for those who do not wish to return to make their intentions known to the government so that their land can be compensated, by the State and made available for those Turkish Speakers who do not wish to return to their villages in the south. I have posted support for turkish speaking cypriots to re-claim their properties in the south and I have thanks to you gotten a different perspective on the settler issue therefore posting that any solution needs to take into consideration the settlers on an individual family basis, with an independent committee looking and assessing applicant wishing to stay on. Once again the number of settlers tostay to go to a referendum for turkish cypriots to determine the percentage if any. I have posted for the RoC to provide tax incentives for turkish speaking cypriot business people to get their business to an EU level for entry into the EU as a unified Island ith one department of commerce.

I have not pushed you aside at all Zan. You are choosing to separate and compartmentalise people. I see us all as one Cypriot people, I do not say things like I want us to be with OUR own. You do that. I want a one Cyprus for all Cypriots. As far as you choosing to feel more Turkish than Cypriot that is your choosing it is not my pushing you to do so. As I choose to not identify as Greek you choose to identify as Turkish and NOT Cypriot. You can choose to be Cypriot anytime you like. I guess though that requires one thing and that is fighting for one Cyprus for all Cypriot people. Are you willing to fight for a united Cyprus Zan. A trully United Cyprus where all its people share and have access to same human rights, political representation, economic participation social development and a cultural evolution.

As far as the concession you are asking for, I do not support a segrated Cyprus, I do not agree or support that people are not given the right of return I do not agree that turkish speaking cypriots not have equal access to the natural resources under a unified Cyprus.

As far as fighting for my corner you are wrong. I am fighting that the RoC implement policies and create a judicial system that will stamp out racism, discriminatin and violence against any of its citizens. I am asking that all Cypriots have equal rights in all domains of our society. I am not saying that I want the right of return for all greeks refugees and bugger the rights of turkish speaking cypriots who cannot return to their properties I am saying everyone ought have the right of return and I am also advocating that turkish speaking cypriots receive financial assistance to rebuild their properties as should greek speaking cypriots. I am also advocating for the Church to habd over some of their land in the north to rehouse turkish speaking cypriots. If that is only advicating for one portion of the population then I am guilty of your accusations and I acknowledge that they are just that yours.

Woof..... watch out from the big bad woolf aka humanist. or should that be greek humanist? :)
User avatar
humanist
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 6585
Joined: Fri Nov 10, 2006 11:46 am

Postby Murataga » Mon Apr 23, 2007 7:10 am

@Zan- Welcome back, we missed you. I am so sorry about you health. I hope you will get well soon. Please keep us posted and let me know if there is anything I can do.

@humanist- I believe Zan and Viewpoint have clearly answered your post. There isn`t much I will add to their logical answers. However, I wish to make a correction in your post regarding a comment on Enosis. You said:

The fact that it did not succeed tells your that most greek speaking cyp's did not want union with Greece and I for one thank God for it not happenning.


No. The fact that it didn`t succeed does not tell us that the GCs didn`t want it. The fact that it didn`t succeed tells us that the TC resistance and Turkey`s Peace Operation succeeded in deterring this lunatic crusade. GCs wanted Enosis, GCs worked for Enosis, GCs killed for ENosis, GCs slayed the partnership of the two people in RoC for Enosis, GCs preferred independence and freedom over Enosis. I am sorry but it is going to take a little more than an apology to make up for it for human lives and suffering is not that cheap. You ask if we want to live on stolen land: you stabbed us for refusing to succumb to Enosis and now claiming damage because of the blood stain on your knife. Furthermore, I don`t see your people having any problem living in prosperity on a hijacked government and stolen rights of TCS for the past 44 years.

Any GC who wants to talk about the Cyprus conflict and Enosis should first read and memorize the following with the corresponding dates:

(1) Archbishop Makarios III, in an interview with the Frankfurter Rundschau, reported in Cyprus Mail, 16 May 1974 (!)

"Enosis had always been for the Greek Cypriots a deeprooted national aspiration. To me independence is a comprimise. In other words, if I had a free choice between ENOSIS and independence, I would support ENOSIS."

(2) Archbishop Makarios III, in an interview given to the Norwegian newspaper Dagbladet, 12 March 1977 (!)

"It is in the name of ENOSIS that Cyprus has been destroyed"


ENosis was prooved to the GCs as something they will never be able to accomplish with the stiff Turkish resistance in Cyprus. Make no mistake about this.
User avatar
Murataga
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 824
Joined: Mon Nov 27, 2006 5:32 pm

Postby Murataga » Mon Apr 23, 2007 7:29 am

sorry about a typo in the previous pots:

GCs preferred independence and freedom over Enosis


is obvioulsy vice versa given the context of the post:

GCs preferred Enosis over independence and freedom
User avatar
Murataga
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 824
Joined: Mon Nov 27, 2006 5:32 pm

Postby humanist » Mon Apr 23, 2007 7:50 am

Now you are telling me what I am supposed to want for myself? Thank you marataga.
User avatar
humanist
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 6585
Joined: Fri Nov 10, 2006 11:46 am

Postby Murataga » Mon Apr 23, 2007 7:54 am

No that is not what I am telling you. I am telling you what the majority of the GCs wanted over their independence in Cyprus and the illegalities they have committed to achieve it.
User avatar
Murataga
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 824
Joined: Mon Nov 27, 2006 5:32 pm

Postby Murataga » Mon Apr 23, 2007 7:57 am

humanist: Read it carefully again:

__________________________________________________________

@Zan- Welcome back, we missed you. I am so sorry about you health. I hope you will get well soon. Please keep us posted and let me know if there is anything I can do.

@humanist- I believe Zan and Viewpoint have clearly answered your post. There isn`t much I will add to their logical answers. However, I wish to make a correction in your post regarding a comment on Enosis. You said:

Quote:
The fact that it did not succeed tells your that most greek speaking cyp's did not want union with Greece and I for one thank God for it not happenning.


No. The fact that it didn`t succeed does not tell us that the GCs didn`t want it. The fact that it didn`t succeed tells us that the TC resistance and Turkey`s Peace Operation succeeded in deterring this lunatic crusade. GCs wanted Enosis, GCs worked for Enosis, GCs killed for ENosis, GCs slayed the partnership of the two people in RoC for Enosis, GCs preferred Enosis over independence and freedom. I am sorry but it is going to take a little more than an apology to make up for it for human lives and suffering is not that cheap. You ask if we want to live on stolen land: you stabbed us for refusing to succumb to Enosis and now claiming damage because of the blood stain on your knife. Furthermore, I don`t see your people having any problem living in prosperity on a hijacked government and stolen rights of TCS for the past 44 years.

Any GC who wants to talk about the Cyprus conflict and Enosis should first read and memorize the following with the corresponding dates:

(1) Archbishop Makarios III, in an interview with the Frankfurter Rundschau, reported in Cyprus Mail, 16 May 1974 (!)

"Enosis had always been for the Greek Cypriots a deeprooted national aspiration. To me independence is a comprimise. In other words, if I had a free choice between ENOSIS and independence, I would support ENOSIS."

(2) Archbishop Makarios III, in an interview given to the Norwegian newspaper Dagbladet, 12 March 1977 (!)

"It is in the name of ENOSIS that Cyprus has been destroyed"

Enosis was prooved to the GCs as something they will never be able to accomplish with the stiff Turkish resistance in Cyprus. Make no mistake about this.
User avatar
Murataga
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 824
Joined: Mon Nov 27, 2006 5:32 pm

Postby Viewpoint » Mon Apr 23, 2007 8:17 am

Murataga wrote:@Zan- Welcome back, we missed you. I am so sorry about you health. I hope you will get well soon. Please keep us posted and let me know if there is anything I can do.

@humanist- I believe Zan and Viewpoint have clearly answered your post. There isn`t much I will add to their logical answers. However, I wish to make a correction in your post regarding a comment on Enosis. You said:

The fact that it did not succeed tells your that most greek speaking cyp's did not want union with Greece and I for one thank God for it not happenning.


No. The fact that it didn`t succeed does not tell us that the GCs didn`t want it. The fact that it didn`t succeed tells us that the TC resistance and Turkey`s Peace Operation succeeded in deterring this lunatic crusade. GCs wanted Enosis, GCs worked for Enosis, GCs killed for ENosis, GCs slayed the partnership of the two people in RoC for Enosis, GCs preferred independence and freedom over Enosis. I am sorry but it is going to take a little more than an apology to make up for it for human lives and suffering is not that cheap. You ask if we want to live on stolen land: you stabbed us for refusing to succumb to Enosis and now claiming damage because of the blood stain on your knife. Furthermore, I don`t see your people having any problem living in prosperity on a hijacked government and stolen rights of TCS for the past 44 years.

Any GC who wants to talk about the Cyprus conflict and Enosis should first read and memorize the following with the corresponding dates:

(1) Archbishop Makarios III, in an interview with the Frankfurter Rundschau, reported in Cyprus Mail, 16 May 1974 (!)

"Enosis had always been for the Greek Cypriots a deeprooted national aspiration. To me independence is a comprimise. In other words, if I had a free choice between ENOSIS and independence, I would support ENOSIS."

(2) Archbishop Makarios III, in an interview given to the Norwegian newspaper Dagbladet, 12 March 1977 (!)

"It is in the name of ENOSIS that Cyprus has been destroyed"


ENosis was prooved to the GCs as something they will never be able to accomplish with the stiff Turkish resistance in Cyprus. Make no mistake about this.


excellent post, well expressed and the thoughts of many TCs.
User avatar
Viewpoint
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 25214
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 2:48 pm
Location: Nicosia/Lefkosa

Postby humanist » Mon Apr 23, 2007 8:22 am

Yes Murataga, I know that human lives have been lost My 17 year old uncle was killed by the turks in the 74 invasion. Yet I am willing for a unified Cyprus and all its people.

Make no mistake that the stiff resistance in Cyprus from the Turkish side has come and will forever becoming from the Turks not the Turkish speaking Cypriots, Besides that if there ever was and there never will be an attempt towards such a stupid pathetic notion again, but for arguments sake lets say there will be I will be standing next to you fighting for something different. So long as I agreed with it.

VP about my choice, I have no choice in buying land in the north especially one that has not been stolen from a refugee.
User avatar
humanist
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 6585
Joined: Fri Nov 10, 2006 11:46 am

PreviousNext

Return to Cyprus Problem

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests